NEW YORK, 12:33 PM, TUE MAY 13 | 61 POSTS IN THE LAST 24 HOURS | tips@gawker.com | SUBMIT A TIP | RSS

Blood-Thirsty Pundits Demand Violent End to Primaries

MSNBC pundit Keith Olbermann on how to deal with Hillary Clinton's never-ending campaign: "Right. Somebody who can take her into a room and only he comes out." Ok! As HuffPo's Rachel Sklar points out, that means he would like someone to beat her up. Metaphorically! Also, sexistly! Well, it's maybe debatable. Like that New Republic cover. Clearly stupid, but scale of 1-10, how vile? We won't wade in! We will say, though, that it's not even the worst of recent cable news comments.

The Daily Show covered this the other night. Skip to about three minutes in, when the pundits demand blood. "Look, we gotta kill her off—y'know, figuratively."

Sklar says: "To the fellow (male) journo I wrote to about this yesterday, who waved it off as just some colorful film-noir imagery, I say: can you IMAGINE if someone had said that about Obama?" Well we need imagine no more! Lovable old Pat Buchanan does do this in the clip above, when he mentions how often Hillary Clinton has "whipped" Obama. What a colorful image, a white lady repeatedly whipping a black man! But it's Pat Buchanan, no one even notices when he's casually racist anymore. (And obviously most of the grosser comments in the clip are directed at or about Senator Clinton.)

Cable news idiots just love violent imagery, they depend on it to make their miserable analyses sound exciting, and they're being utterly clueless when they use this imagery against Hillary Clinton. Which, once again, reinforcing misogyny. So shame on Olbermann!

Anyway, now you get to have a big comments fight about it!

1:56 PM on Fri Apr 25 2008
By Pareene
1,123 views
25 comments

Comments

  • Let's get her pregnant! Knocked up and barefoot, that's the way.

  • I've been hoping they would settle this with a knife fight for quite some time, but Olberman gets closer to the real solution:

    Thunderdome. Two Will Enter. One Will Leave.

  • Olberman's pretty awful. Not Pete Dougherty armpit awful, more like Amy Winehouse's sheets awful.

  • At this point the dems should just start handing out McCain '08 bumper stickers. It's sad, mildly amusing, and even somewhat embarrassing watching them pry defeat from the jaws of victory once again.

  • I'm so fucking bored by the inanity of humanity.

    And whale-song.

  • @Furious George: i always wondered how the democratic party would lose the election this year. now i know.

  • The wrestlers wade in, though
    for all intensive purposes,
    they were prostate with grief.

  • I thought Olberman meant Hil would emerge from the room as a penis owner. Oh well.

  • I don't believe the conventional wisdom that the longer this goes on the worst it is for the party. I think it's good for the party and it's good for the country. Everyone's paying attention. I think the exasberation from the pundits is having more people paying attention and throwing out their two cents than normal inside the beltway boys and everyone knows what happens when you get too many cooks in the kitchen. But this is actually good. Everyone used to bemoan the state of political interest and now that they have it, they want it to go away. An evenly matched fued is good, not bad. Now if we can just focus on issues of substance instead of, say, flag lapels and such (I'm looking at you ABC!)

  • I suspect the Democratic nominee was picked months ago and Ashton Kutcher has just been toying with us ever since.

  • Image of lawyergay lawyergay at 02:49 PM on 04/25/08 *

    I actually read about that Olbermann quote yesterday and was immediately appalled and then watched it (and replayed it several times) last night. Granted, he is embarrassingly pro-Obama, but what I THINK he meant was that only Obama comes out, and that he was using a really bad and too easily interpreted as wife-beatery metaphor for some kind of smoke filled room-type of negotiation that would result in Hillary dropping out. But then again, he did have that rabid gleam in his eye when he said it. Or was it the Oliver People's glasses? I can't tell anymore.

  • I'd take Sklar more seriously about femiladyism if she wasn't directly involved in the advancement of Obama Girl.

  • @LoveHandles:

    Inviting more people into the process does the opposite of what you say it does. More Americans expressing their political opinions and participating in the process = much more inane crap. Every additional voter Southwest of Philadelphia and East of LA that cares about this election is another voter that cares about lapel pins.

  • @LoveHandles: not really. have you seen the debates? the questions are stupid, the moderators inept, and the voters in these states are just looking bad (or the media shows them to be so) by focusing on flag lapels and pastors.

  • @bess marvin, girl detective:

    That's Democracy, though.

    Of course, Democracy is done best when the idiots stay home.

  • keith olbermann said something stupid and offensive. nope, i got nothing.

  • RE: The Debates
    That's right, because listening to Barack and Hillary say for the 22nd time they're going to take the troops out of Iraq and repeal Nafta is going to tell us so much more. What they should do is get 'em in a game of "Your mama's so fat" and let 'em go at it ... or, in this case, "Your mama's so white"


  • @bess marvin, girl detective: @ADismalScience: I agree that the more people that pay attention the more the media feels the need to focus on these silly contrived controversies. But look at the backlash against ABC for their god-awful debate. It was pretty strong and widespread. I think a vast majority of people saw it for what it was and I'm sure ABC wish they had a do-over.

    But, in the end, you're both right. The more people that pay attention, the more simplified the coverage has to be for major media outlets. This is becuase the average political IQ of most Americans is not that high. We know that. Doesn't make them bad people. I think it's a bit elitist though to say that they don't have the right to get interested now. It kind of points to an elephant in the room if we pay lip service to democracy when only a small percentage of people vote / take interest in politics and we bemoan how dismal that is, then when more people finally do take interest, we get frustrated at how behind they are. They haven't been paying attention... they have to catch up.

    To be clear, I think it's fair to demand more. But... isn't that the problem with democracy? You can't force everyone to be intelligent about the process.. and inevitably, a lot of people won't be. So what do we really want? It does, I think, come down to asking ourselves: are we really for democracy or not?

  • @LoveHandles:

    The backlash was media-driven. Your average American, like it or not, DOES care about why or why not Barack Obama wears a flag lapel pin.

    Political debates are designed to provoke discussion about the unique characteristics and brand of the politicians involved. To date, no debate has accomplished that mission as effectively as ABC. You can hate that these issues are important, but you can't hate ABC for having the finger on America's stupid pulse.

  • @ADismalScience: Yup. Is Facism not in vogue anymore? If not, can we bring it back?

  • @SpecialK: What about "your momma's so Nafta?" Would that work?

  • @Notyourmother: "Your mama's so mandatory healthcare"

    "Your mama's so tax and spend"

    "Your mama's so 100-year-war"

  • @SpecialK: This is so interesting. I have never questioned my Obama-Girl love and my lady-love. I just think the whole Obama Girl thing is hilarious, and I don't find it demeaning or damaging - it's tongue in cheek which is part of the joke. Does that make me sexist? Issues are hard!

  • The beauty of it is, I'd bitch at you if you took Obama Girl seriously, so you can't win! Identity politics rawk!

  • @VirusWithShoes: Hey, you stole my thought! I'm figuratively beating you up for that.

Comment on this post

Reply by Email

Login with your username and password below. Or comment on this post via email.