This is relevant to my interests—and not just because I was in my high school's production of Once Upon a Mattress. See a young Zooey sing "In a Little While" with Glee's Matthew Morrison.
Man, the 90s were cruel to everyone. Or is it made-for-TV movies I'm thinking of? Either way, I bet this is one tape from the vault that neither actor ever wanted to see again. UPDATE: a quick imdb search shows that this was made in 2005. Say it isn't so!