Gawker

'Seventeen' Teaches About Tactful Whoring

So here's a question a reader just posed. Take a look at the "Pretty Makeup Ideas" feature in the December Seventeen, out last week, and tell us: Is it editorial or advertising? It sure doesn't say "advertisement" on it anywhere, and it's got a byline, which makes you think it's edit. But, then, it also has spreads like this one, which make you think it's got to be ad:
20051109seventeensmall.jpg
We're sort of assuming money changed hands for this, but, really, we have no idea.

Then again, we don't have nearly the critical-reading sophistication of Seventeen's target readership, who no doubt aren't tricked by this at all.

Check out the full feature — also featuring ads for, er, editorial on Estee Lauder, Clinique, M.A.C., and Chanel — after the jump, and help us understand.

Click on each image to enlarge.
20051109seventeen1.jpg
20051109seventeen2.jpg
20051109seventeen3.jpg
20051109seventeen4.jpg
20051109seventeen5.jpg
20051109seventeen6.jpg

11:22 AM on Wed Nov 9 2005
By Jesse
85 views
10 comments