An Oakland man enraged by a friend's attempt to disprove the existence of God reportedly retrieved his AR-15 assault rifle and fired several shots at the man, killing him instantly.
Yim, Phan, and a third friend, Paul Park, were drinking, smoking marijuana, and playing video game in Yim's house in the early morning hours of April 2, 2011, when the ontological argument erupted.
Park said Yim and Phan had also snorted cocaine earlier that night.
According to Park, Phan had been teasing Yim about his religion, asking him where his God was every time he won the game they were playing.
Yim then left the living room, followed by Park and an apologetic Phan.
Their efforts to deescalate the situation proved futile, and Phan, exasperated, told Yim to use the weapon he purchased to protect his basement grow operation to shoot him.
Yim did just that, loading his AR-15 and returning to the dining room where he fired off six shots at Phan, including one aimed at his head from less than a foot away.
A bullet also struck Park's finger as he raised his hand to stop the shooting.