cgi - Gawker

posts about #cgi more →
How the Academy Rigs the Animated Oscar for CGI Behemoths

Your version of Internet Explorer is not supported. Please upgrade to the most recent version in order to view comments.

Dsmvwl Admin Promote to frontpage Approve user Ban user ×

Carol Gardens
11/12/08

In reply to How the Academy Rigs the Animated Oscar for CGI Behemoths
If they didn't have this category animation would get even LESS attention. If it was lumped in with everything else you would occasionally see a Pixar up for best picture and that's about it. Just FYI, there are the ANNIES, if you want a better idea of what's up each year in animation:

[www.annieawards.org]
Reply

Carol Gardens was starred Carol Gardens was unstarred

skahammer
11/12/08

In reply to How the Academy Rigs the Animated Oscar for CGI Behemoths
I suppose the option of ignoring the politics of Oscar noms is just too troublesome?
Reply

skahammer was starred skahammer was unstarred

Cosette
11/11/08

In reply to How the Academy Rigs the Animated Oscar for CGI Behemoths
Waltz with Bashir's execution of such political issues..! Never has a film captured the sense of dissociation/depersonalization amongst soldiers/civilians in war time as did this work; namely, the recurring scene wherein the soldiers, zombie-like and listless, (re) emerge out of the water...(don't worry this spoils absolutely nothing)...

I rarely speak effusively of films, but this particular work resonated with me for days.
Reply

Cosette was starred Cosette was unstarred

Uncle_Billy_Slumming
11/12/08

@Cosette:

I had to share that after reading your post, I would like to resonate with you for days too. That's all. Carry on.
Reply

Cosette
11/12/08

@Uncle_Billy_Slumming but are you as intricately wrought with equal parts pained/ambivalent opacity and haunting numbness? so amazing..
Reply

Cosette was starred Cosette was unstarred

Uncle_Billy_Slumming
11/12/08

@Cosette:

Now I have to see the movie. Yes, that's me exactly.
Reply

Mount_Prion
11/11/08

In reply to How the Academy Rigs the Animated Oscar for CGI Behemoths
I'm hoping in the future the world will be nerdy enough for "Anime" to have its own category, although it will be difficult to classify what fits into that with the crossbreeding of American and Asian styles. Personally, few animated films have made me happier than Wall-E and The Iron Giant but I can't even effectively compare them mentally to feature Anime films.
Reply

Mount_Prion was starred Mount_Prion was unstarred

Mark 2000
11/11/08

In reply to How the Academy Rigs the Animated Oscar for CGI Behemoths
Down with Pixar, for goodness sake. I mean, their stuff is good, but Persepolis was so much better artistically and storywise than the cooking rat. The should just call the Animation oscar the Pixar Oscar at this rate.
Reply

Mark 2000 was starred Mark 2000 was unstarred

homoviper
11/11/08

@Mark 2000: This brings up a question I haven't taken the time to look up the answer to and maybe you or someone else knows, is the Oscar for animated film supposed to be given to the best technical achievement in animation or the best overall artistic achievement rendered in animation or is it basically whatever the hell the academy voters think at the time?
Reply

homoviper was starred homoviper was unstarred

happymisanthrope
11/11/08

@Mark 2000: really? I found Persepolis to be episodic. It was something I could enjoy but not really love. Ratatouille is a movie I fell in love with.

And WALL*E takes chances, artistically speaking, and it doesn't talk down to audience the way most movies -- for children or adults -- do.
Reply

happymisanthrope was starred happymisanthrope was unstarred

franklinshepard
11/11/08

In reply to How the Academy Rigs the Animated Oscar for CGI Behemoths
Question: that list isn't every animated film that came out this past year, right? Where's Space Chimps? Why would an animated movie come out that wasn't submitting for consideration for this award?
Reply

franklinshepard was starred franklinshepard was unstarred

Carol Gardens
11/12/08

@franklinshepard: Maybe Space Chimps wasn't entered ecause it really sucked. Even my nephew didn't like it and he likes everything animated. They only need 16 entries to bump up to 5 nominees. It is up to the studios to submit. So the list does not reflect all the films that came out; it is those that qualified and were submitted.
Reply

Carol Gardens was starred Carol Gardens was unstarred

homoviper
11/11/08

In reply to How the Academy Rigs the Animated Oscar for CGI Behemoths
For what it's worth, Bashir, I believe, is also being submitted for the foreign language film Oscar.
Reply

homoviper was starred homoviper was unstarred

Triborough
11/11/08

In reply to How the Academy Rigs the Animated Oscar for CGI Behemoths
I stopped caring about the Oscars years ago. They are just a useless waste of time.
Reply

Triborough was starred Triborough was unstarred

Mount_Prion
11/11/08

@Triborough: "I also don't care about politics, oh audience reading comments on a political post. And I want you to know."

<3
Reply

Mount_Prion was starred Mount_Prion was unstarred

MercuryPDX
11/11/08

In reply to How the Academy Rigs the Animated Oscar for CGI Behemoths
the statue has only gone to a non-Hollywood production had something to once, when Japanese-bankrolled phenomenon Spirited Away nabbed the prize.

I'm sure being affiliated with Buena Vista (aka Disney) didn't hurt its chances at either making the list or winning. ;)

I fully agree that there shouldn't be a "cap". They can just lump it into the "Awards we gave out but you didn't see on TV" category if time constraints are the only reason.
Reply

MercuryPDX was starred MercuryPDX was unstarred

Weegee's bored
11/11/08

In reply to How the Academy Rigs the Animated Oscar for CGI Behemoths
If Ratatouille didn't get an Oscar, nobody gets an Oscar.
Reply

Weegee's bored was starred Weegee's bored was unstarred

jenalicious
11/11/08

In reply to How the Academy Rigs the Animated Oscar for CGI Behemoths
i want to feel bad for the little animated movies that could, but can't. there are gazillions of independent films made every year, and its the same story. they never get the accolades they should, and how could they with the hollywood system churning out hugely budgeted films. and now, hugely budgeted "art" films.
Reply

jenalicious was starred jenalicious was unstarred

Uncle_Billy_Slumming
11/11/08

In reply to How the Academy Rigs the Animated Oscar for CGI Behemoths
They can't. We need more cowb... er, categories.

Also, I'll ask the question that's been asked before again: Why, when you click on someone's name to see their previous comments, does a picture of dead che guevara show up in the side banner?
Reply

Earlier discussions Other discussions Show all discussions Show featured discussions only Start a new discussion

#cgi

Gawker

SUBSCRIBE TO Gawker

How the Academy Rigs the Animated Oscar for CGI Behemoths

Login

Reset Password

Register

Submit Your Comment