Dig deeper Hamilton! This is on top of the current problem... which is that they had a big melt, the water inundated the drains, then froze, then they had another big melt, but the drains remained frozen so the water had no where to go. On top of that, *now* they're going to have a record flood. (Or maybe that's just another city on the Red River...)
Step away from the newsfeed, guys. Don't hoard bread yet. Spring wheat is planted in the spring, not like winter as it is in Kansas and points south.
But if the fields don't dry out by late april, then go hoard your bread. Or learn to like rice and oats.
BTW, the red river valley is one of the freaking flattest places in the world. Once the water tops those dikes (isn't dykes the original spelling?) you're filling up a gigantic wading pool---there's nothing stopping you for about 20 miles either side.
@dc garage shooter: That just means there's more country to soak up that river. See, you take 42" of flood stage and distribute it from there to Bismark, and you'll be surprised it ain't that tall when it arrives. I don't know why that is, but I think Newton had something to do with it.
A large flat surface, like where I was raised, 12 miles from another Red River, will sap an overflow, same as milk spilled on your table will run out of milk often before it runs out of table. That's why we never had a flood, although the river rose often.
@Tremonius: Not sure what you mean by "Reload," but anyway, yes, that's usually what happens in and around Fargo. But as Sig mentions, when the ground is too saturated, the floodwaters just roll over it. Also, the houses that are in real trouble aren't 12 miles away -- they're half a mile to a mile.
This is going to be a horrible event for the people going through it now, but our Gov't needs to recognize a problem and step in NOW to prevent food shortages for later this year.
This isn't just a city getting flooded. This is a major agricultural disaster about to happen, and it's going to cause ALL KINDS of problems later if it's not addressed.
Maybe this is a dumb idea, but ND is pretty empty, all things considered. Can't they just purposefully flood upriver, taking the pressure of the dikes?
@psthmn: And flood Canada? No way?? Wait. That's already going to happen.
Former GF resident here. Good gracious almighty the floods that happen along that river suck ass. I got in and out of there as quickly as possible and (luckily) avoided any major flooding, but I worried the whole town. Still have friends who live there. My heart goes out to them.
@psthmn: I think rivers generally flood where they flood. It would probably take some sort of incredible movement of tens of thousands of tons of dirt to make a lowland where the river could drain into.
@FracturedAcetabulum: I don't think you understood my reply to that previous comment. What part of that was unclear? The town is in a low place - thus the 42 foot dyke, therefore to make the river flood somewhere else requires that that OTHER place be even LOWER. You can't simply make another place flood by force of will.
@psthmn: a huge part of the problem is that the Red River flows north, carrying already-cold water and large chunks of ice into an even colder environment. basically, it created its own ice dam. or something.
@Pope John Peeps II: The water has to go somewhere. A 42 foot dyke (heh heh) assures the residents of Fargo, ND that the North-flowing Red River won't flood in their town,. It pushes it further to Grand Forks, ND. Grand Forks expects to see 54 feet of water. Their dikes are built to sustaing 45-50 feet (they had 54 in 1997 with the huge flood).
That's why. The water has to go somewhere. The bigger dikes only postpone where the water dumps.
@Dr. Nick: Really, a huge part of the problem is that there's never been a flood of this magnitude in the area in anyone's lifetime. '93 and '97 were nothing compared to this, and they happened without a shitload of snow on the ground, too.
@FracturedAcetabulum: We like you around here, FracturedAcetabulum, but I get the feeling that you moving in, even briefly, would worry the whole of any town.
@Pope John Peeps II: The other place needs to be lower than the dikes, not lower than the city.
It is a radical solution with a worth hanging on how bad the flood is really going to get. But if the possibility of flooding is so high as to be practically certain, it could be cheaper to choose where it's gonna happen.
@psthmn: Well, they have until tomorrow or maybe later tonight until the flood crests, so yeah, they should just build some even higher dikes real fast. [Rolling of eyes]
I'm not sure you understand the geography, or what the fuck you're talking about: Fargo and the Red River Valley are flat. Flat like a table. The dikes that do confine the river (which, under normal circumstances, are quite a ways above it) are all man-made -- mounds of dirt that were piled up more than thirty years ago.
To reroute the river would mean piling even more dirt up, even higher, often in places that are hard to reach because there are houses all around -- many of which have never been in serious danger of flooding until this week. (There used to be a number of homes that were simply built too close to the river, for aesthetic reasons; after the flood of '97, the city told a lot of those owners that no, they couldn't rebuild there, which was a blessing because everyone was sick of devoting dozens of man-hours to sandbagging so that a few people could have scenic backyards.) Things are also complicated by the fact that, as others have noted, the river runs north and Fargo has a large set of sewage holding pools just north of town.
Anyway, "cheaper" is not the pertinent issue here. It's time. If dirt could be piled up quickly instead of HESCO barriers and sandbags, I'm sure they'd do it.
@Moff: Being currently in Grand Forks I can tell you that a lot of people here are spooked even though the dikes here are well above projected river peaks (in GF). They think they're going to fail. (could happen). Many Grand Forks residents wanted to bus down to sandbag and help but a 2 day blizzard with white out conditions closed hwy. 29, and made that impossible for the last 2 days.
And if you think that photo sucks, it's always good to look back on the one of GF in 1997.
Yeah, that's NOT photoshopped. Yes, that is a flooded city... on fire.
Winnipeg built flood control systems years ago... upriver, Grand Forks got flooded. Grand Forks built flood control systems, Fargo floods. Fargo never built a system like GF has because they didn't have the millions and millions in Federal disaster aid post-flood in 1997.
@SigSauer: Well, and Fargo also didn't build one because, as Excited_Utterance points out, what happened in '97 was thought to be a once-in-a-lifetime occurrence. I'm sure it was discussed, numbers were crunched, and the math said that it would be a lot cheaper to drag out the sandbags on the off chance it ever happened again than to build a whole new system, forcing a bunch of people out of their homes in the process.
You guys got it bad back then. From what I'm hearing from back home, there aren't a lot of worries of fires and the like yet, but the weather is just making everything absolutely miserable.
@Moff: True. It was discussed. And as I'm sure you're aware, ND local governments are notoriously penny pinching. Hell, the GF mayor--a city of 50K plus including a Univ.-- is PART TIME. He only works something like Mondays and some nights.
But also, we were hearing the flood warning back in Dec. when we had record snowfall levels already AND more importantly a very wet ground from fall rains. Alot of people in GF are especially the more... independent NDers... living in the countryside kind of roll their eyes at Fargo and in the very straight-forward ND way think they're getting what they deserve for ignoring early warnings. Not that that's totally the case. Because the flood peak targets keep getting higher and higher. There was a great deal of local celebration when the dikes hit like 41 feet and then the projects came at "maybe 43" and everyone was crushed.
For great coverage of this Grand Forks Herald's Tu-Uyen Tran blogs at [www.areavoices.com]
Check him out especially for the note he got from the westboro baptist church: "God sent the flood waters to cover the evil people of Bismarck and Fargo, ND, where you flipped off God and raised you.." If you're a ND native, you'll recognize the type.
@SigSauer: Ah, yes. Good ol' Westboro Church. What I don't get is, we have a fair number of native North Dakotans who basically share their beliefs, so why is God punishing them along with everyone else?
I didn't realize there had been so much warning that it could be this bad, but then, that's people in general for you and, yes, cheap North Dakotans in particular: "Oh, it won't be that bad." Besides, the hard work just builds character, right?
@Moff: Just a quick question. If the Red River Valley is flat as a table, then how does a river run through it at all, to any depth, at any time, in either direction?
@SigSauer: In floods of prior years, the white citizens of Nawleans made the sensible decision to go upriver and bomb the levies and flood Black neighborhoods.
@Tremonius: I apologize for confounding you with my use of hyperbole. Obviously, there must be a drop from south to north. So think of it as a table tilted slightly, if that's less confusing.
@psthmn: yeah. I totally see where you're going. But dykes are only built up to the level of the land in other areas. They're built in areas that would normally flood because they can't flood anywhere else. So it seems that logically there would be nowhere else for this river TO flood. And besides, if the river does crest these dykes, anywhere where there ISN'T a dyke would already be flooded, no?
@SigSauer: Oh, yes -- my high school girlfriend's father's dream (yes, dream) was for his kids to graduate so he could move to West Fargo and not pay property taxes.
(Why, some of you may ask, didn't he just go ahead and move while the kids were still in school? Because he had daughters, and everyone knows that West Fargo girls are huge sluts. Bigger sluts than Moorhead girls, even, if you can believe that.)
03/28/09
03/27/09
03/27/09
03/27/09
We will miss your bright eyes and sweet smile
For they say you are taking the sunshine
That has brightened our pathways awhile
CHORUS:
Come and sit by my side, if you love me
Do not hasten to bid me adieu
Just remember the Red River Valley
And the cowboy who loved you so true
I've been thinking a long time, my darling
Of the sweet words you never would say
Now, alas, must my fond hopes all vanish
For they say you are gong away
Do you think of the valley you're leaving
O how lonely and how dreary it will be
And do you think of the kind hearts you're breaking
And the pain you are causing to me
CHORUS
They will bury me where you have wandered
Near the hills where the daffodils grow
When you're gone from the Red River Valley
For I can't live without you I know
CHORUS
03/27/09
03/27/09
03/27/09
three-car garage = gearhead. Not to say he isn't a sick bastard, but he's probably a sick bastard who builds cars from scratch in his spare time.
03/27/09
03/27/09
Y'all.
03/27/09
03/27/09
03/27/09
03/27/09
I'm having horrifying flashbacks to the sandbag days of my youth.
03/27/09
03/27/09
03/27/09
03/27/09
03/27/09
03/27/09
03/27/09
03/27/09
But if the fields don't dry out by late april, then go hoard your bread. Or learn to like rice and oats.
BTW, the red river valley is one of the freaking flattest places in the world. Once the water tops those dikes (isn't dykes the original spelling?) you're filling up a gigantic wading pool---there's nothing stopping you for about 20 miles either side.
03/27/09
03/27/09
03/27/09
A large flat surface, like where I was raised, 12 miles from another Red River, will sap an overflow, same as milk spilled on your table will run out of milk often before it runs out of table. That's why we never had a flood, although the river rose often.
03/27/09
03/27/09
03/27/09
03/27/09
This isn't just a city getting flooded. This is a major agricultural disaster about to happen, and it's going to cause ALL KINDS of problems later if it's not addressed.
03/27/09
03/27/09
03/27/09
Former GF resident here. Good gracious almighty the floods that happen along that river suck ass. I got in and out of there as quickly as possible and (luckily) avoided any major flooding, but I worried the whole town. Still have friends who live there. My heart goes out to them.
03/27/09
03/27/09
03/27/09
03/27/09
03/27/09
That's why. The water has to go somewhere. The bigger dikes only postpone where the water dumps.
Which is why Manitoba hates us.
03/27/09
03/27/09
03/27/09
It is a radical solution with a worth hanging on how bad the flood is really going to get. But if the possibility of flooding is so high as to be practically certain, it could be cheaper to choose where it's gonna happen.
03/27/09
I'm not sure you understand the geography, or what the fuck you're talking about: Fargo and the Red River Valley are flat. Flat like a table. The dikes that do confine the river (which, under normal circumstances, are quite a ways above it) are all man-made -- mounds of dirt that were piled up more than thirty years ago.
To reroute the river would mean piling even more dirt up, even higher, often in places that are hard to reach because there are houses all around -- many of which have never been in serious danger of flooding until this week. (There used to be a number of homes that were simply built too close to the river, for aesthetic reasons; after the flood of '97, the city told a lot of those owners that no, they couldn't rebuild there, which was a blessing because everyone was sick of devoting dozens of man-hours to sandbagging so that a few people could have scenic backyards.) Things are also complicated by the fact that, as others have noted, the river runs north and Fargo has a large set of sewage holding pools just north of town.
Anyway, "cheaper" is not the pertinent issue here. It's time. If dirt could be piled up quickly instead of HESCO barriers and sandbags, I'm sure they'd do it.
03/27/09
03/27/09
And if you think that photo sucks, it's always good to look back on the one of GF in 1997.
[www.palaydisplay.com]
Yeah, that's NOT photoshopped. Yes, that is a flooded city... on fire.
Winnipeg built flood control systems years ago... upriver, Grand Forks got flooded. Grand Forks built flood control systems, Fargo floods. Fargo never built a system like GF has because they didn't have the millions and millions in Federal disaster aid post-flood in 1997.
03/27/09
You guys got it bad back then. From what I'm hearing from back home, there aren't a lot of worries of fires and the like yet, but the weather is just making everything absolutely miserable.
03/27/09
But also, we were hearing the flood warning back in Dec. when we had record snowfall levels already AND more importantly a very wet ground from fall rains. Alot of people in GF are especially the more... independent NDers... living in the countryside kind of roll their eyes at Fargo and in the very straight-forward ND way think they're getting what they deserve for ignoring early warnings. Not that that's totally the case. Because the flood peak targets keep getting higher and higher. There was a great deal of local celebration when the dikes hit like 41 feet and then the projects came at "maybe 43" and everyone was crushed.
For great coverage of this Grand Forks Herald's Tu-Uyen Tran blogs at [www.areavoices.com]
Check him out especially for the note he got from the westboro baptist church: "God sent the flood waters to cover the evil people of Bismarck and Fargo, ND, where you flipped off God and raised you.." If you're a ND native, you'll recognize the type.
[www.areavoices.com]
03/27/09
I didn't realize there had been so much warning that it could be this bad, but then, that's people in general for you and, yes, cheap North Dakotans in particular: "Oh, it won't be that bad." Besides, the hard work just builds character, right?
03/27/09
03/27/09
03/27/09
03/27/09
03/27/09
03/28/09
@SigSauer: Oh, yes -- my high school girlfriend's father's dream (yes, dream) was for his kids to graduate so he could move to West Fargo and not pay property taxes.
(Why, some of you may ask, didn't he just go ahead and move while the kids were still in school? Because he had daughters, and everyone knows that West Fargo girls are huge sluts. Bigger sluts than Moorhead girls, even, if you can believe that.)