Ahh! The Might Zenu shall not be pleased! Paul Haggis shall be sent through the highway to the danger zone to battle with the Rain Man.
There will be no vanilla sky for Paul, only days of thunder. A few good men have attempted to disgrace the mighty church of scientology and all have found the mission impossible.
When all is said and done it’s risky business opposing the mighty church and for Paul all that he can hope for is for mercy from the Last Samurai of death, before the young guns of revenge play taps at his funeral #scientology
I'm surprised at some of the responses here. This organization clearly has given a lot to its members in terms of personal growth and/or healing - like baconismyaesthetic's father. To stand on the outside and call it's members "tards", ect is not only cold, but shortsighted. Many members of religious organizations disagree with their churches' stances. I certainly know Catholics who disagree with the misery created world wide by the churches stance on contraception. And, some of them have congregations and priests who stumped for Prop 8. Should they leave the church? Are they "tards" if they don't?
Haggis has clearly had difficulties with his church for some time, and even stated that he refused to cut off his in-laws. The support of Prop 8 by religious groups (not just Scientologist, LDS, and Catholics, but also some Jewish groups, among others) was heartbreaking for many people in those organizations. But any thinking person with a religion will have difficulty at times reconciling their personal beliefs with that of their religion.
And please, can we stop calling it a cult? As an athiest, all religions seem nutty to me, but it's pure bigotry to single out Scientology. I thought we were better than that here. #scientology
@sweetbeans: The Church of Scientology is a cult, by definition. Not cos it's a fruity religion, but because it is literally a cult that practices mind control techniques. #scientology
@Benny: My point wasn't to defend Scientology, but since you bring it up, the definition of "cult" is a system of religious beliefs and ritual. Whether or not they use mind control is kind of beside the point, as that practice isn't limited to cults.
I've certainly read a lot about Scientology that gives me pause, especially the cutting off of non-members (which from what I've read is a better indicator of a cult than mind control is). I do know, however, that Scientology is recognized formally by the US and many other countries as a religion. #scientology
@sweetbeans: Scientology is recognized as a religion by the US for tax purposes -- and only for tax purposes -- because they took the Treasury Department all the way to the Supreme Court. Repeatedly. Treasury finally just gave up, deciding that the resources to continue the fight were better spent elsewhere.
(From a legal standpoint, I think the Scientologists were correct -- if you're going to treat Yom Kippur seat fees -- which are really just payments for good Temple real estate -- as charitable contributions to a religious organization for tax purposes, it's hard to distinguish payments to Scientology for "cleansing" -- again, really just payment for services -- as being substantively different. But that's neither here nor there.)
Also, you have some logical fallacies there. "A system of belief or ritual" is ONE definition of "cult". It's not the one that springs to mind when most people hear or use it, however. And usage of mind control is absolutely relevant to the common definition of "cult" -- which is, as Benny said, a religious group that is potentially non-voluntary with respect to its belief system. #scientology
Living near St. Pete and having been in the middle of protests around the headquaters located in Clearwater I can tell you it gets pretty heated around there. The 'church' has even made pamphlets slandering former members that they have handed out around where the person lives. Regardless of their beliefs the basic practices of the organization is just horrid and awful and ugh, it makes me angry thinking about it. #scientology
The St Petersburg Times coverage certainly was key in helping Paul Haggis and many other Scientologists become aware of what was going on in their church. But Gawker deserves a big pat on the back also. It was Gawker that kept up the Tom Cruise video in January 2008 that has been so helpful in stirring up Anonymous and getting the public interested in Scientology stories. And Gawker has kept up the reporting ever since. Nice work, guys. Now that MSM is finally beginning to come on board, we won't forget the work you did. #scientology
Wow. I can't imagine how painful it must be to do this, and how strongly he must feel about. I think Scientology is nuts, and its leaders pretty much hateful criminals, but I still feel for those who have the scales ripped from their eyes.
Personal sidenote: My mom told me this story. During the 50s or so, my late grandfather was trying to get control of his terrible rages. He was a good man, and a brilliant one, but he had belted the crap out of my mother and some of my aunts and uncles and he wanted to stop. He and a few other men in their 30s started getting together and studying something L. Ron Hubbard came up with. I don't remember what my mom told me it was called, if anything, but they were all big sci fi guys and thought Hubbard was onto something. I assume it was some kind of proto-"clearing." My mom said it mostly seemed to involve meditating and intensely working through...something. I dunno. I heard this second hand!
Anyway, time goes by, and my mother clearly remembers this: One day she came across her father holding a book and shaking his head. "Hubbard's going to turn this into a damn religion, and the minute he does, I'm out."
My mom says my grandfather really did get his shit together, helped in part by this very very very early version of Scientology. I find the story so strange. #scientology
"The Senate cleared a historic hate crimes bill for President Obama's signature Thursday, approving new federal penalties for attacks on gays and lesbians.
The legislation, which was attached to the conference report for the bill outlining the Pentagon's budget, marks the culmination of a years-long fight by civil-rights groups to codify the expanded protections. The law broadens the current definition of federal hate crimes -- which covers attacks motivated by race, color, religion or national origin -- to include those based on gender, sexual orientation, gender identity or disability. It would also create a new federal crime to cover attacks against U.S. military personnel because of their service. "
_________________________
It will be interesting to see how religious groups that have routinely trashed gays (Scientologists, Catholics, hard-core conservative Protestant groups like Repent America or Fred Phelps and his merry gang of wack-a-doodles, etc.) will fare if this new law is enforced.
@dieresis: Right, hate crimes legislation covers actual crimes, or actions, taken against protected groups, not hateful thought or hateful speech. So Fred Phelps is free to continue his abominable protests at soldiers' funerals. Hateful, but still protected. #scientology
What a thoughtful letter. It is obvious why he did this, and he pretty much knows that the attacks and smears are coming in 5,4,3,2,1 I hope his wife leaves as well, but I have a feeling it's going to be him and the in-laws.I think the criticism of "he should have known" is unfair because it doesn't take into account that most of the public attacks on Scientology have been in the last few years. There have been criticisms before that, but the multiple and sustained criticisms has been more recent. The internet has also been a factor.The St.Petersburg piece, the top level executives leaving, and of course creepy Tommy being the face of Scientology, Prop 8, are all recent contributing factors to his awareness. Besides, a "celebrity" it is well known that he was treated differently at the Centre. Knowing all he knows, understanding the ramifications of this, and still doing this in a public way shows a great amount of bravery.
@adiam7: On the other hand anyone with more than six brain cells can tell after about 10 seconds that Scientology is a nasty little cult and that it's followers are tardz. #scientology
@RonnSicTorossian: Imagine what kind of person would more then likely need such a religion. Look at this from their perspective, it feels a need because their an obvious void. I am sure that Scientology is pretty good at figuring out how to "hook" people. i call bullshit on any religion that has disassociation with non members- see Jehovah's as well- but I don't fit the "type" they usually get. I would not get into a room and be audited by anyone but the good ol' I.R. S. #scientology
@arwen1081000: I consider yours a cult too. There is a bit of fantasy in all "religion" but some are easier to call BS on then others. How many of you are getting into heaven again? What is it like 116,580 or some other very specific number that is very close to this .This is all people since the beginning of time. Everyone else earth who is a Witness, earth will be made into heaven am I correct? So the ones that actually get into "heaven" are sort of in the VIP club.Are you able to marry , hang out, associate with non Witnesses? If your family/ friends does not join you aren't you to disassociate from them? How much money are you to give the Kingdom Hall and how many hours of free service? Also, you don't vote correct? It is "of this world" so you can't be bothered by that. I remember being approached by a Witness , that I only stopped for because she was damn near 100, at the hospital on a Saturday. She saw the panic on my face and I thought she wanted to help me get my nephew some help, but I was wrong. After I told her I was looking for the valet guys that are usually there Mon-Fri, since I had never been there on a Sat. and I needed to get this 3 year-old to the doctor she wanted to talk to me about becoming a Witness. If I did not have a sick 3 year-old with me I would have cursed her ass out no matter how old she was, I noticed that it was a gang of them there at least 8 or so. Who goes to a hospital to look for people who might feel weak and desperate? I know who, predators. I could go on about Jehovah business holdings, tax-empt status, proselytizing , celebrities, missionary work, and the specific targeting of third world nations. Sound familiar? #scientology
@robina: If he walks his Best Picture Oscar over to Focus Features, the circle will be complete. But I cheer his achievement even if he doesn't. #scientology
10/26/09
There will be no vanilla sky for Paul, only days of thunder. A few good men have attempted to disgrace the mighty church of scientology and all have found the mission impossible.
When all is said and done it’s risky business opposing the mighty church and for Paul all that he can hope for is for mercy from the Last Samurai of death, before the young guns of revenge play taps at his funeral #scientology
10/26/09
10/26/09
10/26/09
Is that a condom joke? #hughhefner
10/26/09
Haggis has clearly had difficulties with his church for some time, and even stated that he refused to cut off his in-laws. The support of Prop 8 by religious groups (not just Scientologist, LDS, and Catholics, but also some Jewish groups, among others) was heartbreaking for many people in those organizations. But any thinking person with a religion will have difficulty at times reconciling their personal beliefs with that of their religion.
And please, can we stop calling it a cult? As an athiest, all religions seem nutty to me, but it's pure bigotry to single out Scientology. I thought we were better than that here. #scientology
10/26/09
10/26/09
I've certainly read a lot about Scientology that gives me pause, especially the cutting off of non-members (which from what I've read is a better indicator of a cult than mind control is). I do know, however, that Scientology is recognized formally by the US and many other countries as a religion. #scientology
10/26/09
(From a legal standpoint, I think the Scientologists were correct -- if you're going to treat Yom Kippur seat fees -- which are really just payments for good Temple real estate -- as charitable contributions to a religious organization for tax purposes, it's hard to distinguish payments to Scientology for "cleansing" -- again, really just payment for services -- as being substantively different. But that's neither here nor there.)
Also, you have some logical fallacies there. "A system of belief or ritual" is ONE definition of "cult". It's not the one that springs to mind when most people hear or use it, however. And usage of mind control is absolutely relevant to the common definition of "cult" -- which is, as Benny said, a religious group that is potentially non-voluntary with respect to its belief system. #scientology
10/26/09
Almost. #scientology
10/26/09
10/26/09
10/26/09
10/26/09
10/26/09
Personal sidenote: My mom told me this story. During the 50s or so, my late grandfather was trying to get control of his terrible rages. He was a good man, and a brilliant one, but he had belted the crap out of my mother and some of my aunts and uncles and he wanted to stop. He and a few other men in their 30s started getting together and studying something L. Ron Hubbard came up with. I don't remember what my mom told me it was called, if anything, but they were all big sci fi guys and thought Hubbard was onto something. I assume it was some kind of proto-"clearing." My mom said it mostly seemed to involve meditating and intensely working through...something. I dunno. I heard this second hand!
Anyway, time goes by, and my mother clearly remembers this: One day she came across her father holding a book and shaking his head. "Hubbard's going to turn this into a damn religion, and the minute he does, I'm out."
My mom says my grandfather really did get his shit together, helped in part by this very very very early version of Scientology. I find the story so strange. #scientology
10/26/09
10/26/09
The legislation, which was attached to the conference report for the bill outlining the Pentagon's budget, marks the culmination of a years-long fight by civil-rights groups to codify the expanded protections. The law broadens the current definition of federal hate crimes -- which covers attacks motivated by race, color, religion or national origin -- to include those based on gender, sexual orientation, gender identity or disability. It would also create a new federal crime to cover attacks against U.S. military personnel because of their service. "
_________________________
It will be interesting to see how religious groups that have routinely trashed gays (Scientologists, Catholics, hard-core conservative Protestant groups like Repent America or Fred Phelps and his merry gang of wack-a-doodles, etc.) will fare if this new law is enforced.
[IMG][i240.photobucket.com]] #scientology
10/26/09
10/26/09
Anyway, as far as I can tell, hate-crimes laws don’t change the legal position of religious groups. #scientology
10/26/09
10/26/09
Hugh's epitaph: If this graves a-rockin' don't come a-knockin' #hughhefner
10/26/09
10/26/09
Okay, so I barely know who this guy is and I only heard Crash was stupid, but still! Eeee! #scientology
10/25/09
Yikes
[www.lermanet.com] #scientology
10/25/09
10/26/09
10/26/09
10/26/09
10/27/09
10/25/09
10/25/09