hailey mac arthur

posts about #haileymacarthur more →
Small Town Newspaper Intern Canned For Plagiarizing New York Times

Your version of Internet Explorer is not supported. Please upgrade to the most recent version in order to view comments.

Dsmvwl Admin Promote to frontpage Approve user Ban user ×

Alaska Miller
07/08/09

In reply to Small Town Newspaper Intern Canned For Plagiarizing New York Times
College kids are funny.
Reply

Alaska Miller was starred Alaska Miller was unstarred

Mo MoDo
07/08/09

In reply to Small Town Newspaper Intern Canned For Plagiarizing New York Times
Plagiarism lesson: Write for years, get a NYT column, win a Pulitzer and THEN start stealing from people. Kids today just don't want to put in the time.
Reply

Mo MoDo was starred Mo MoDo was unstarred

eeeradicator
07/08/09

In reply to Small Town Newspaper Intern Canned For Plagiarizing New York Times
She is a second year college student, and I am supposed to be surprised that she cheats on assignments? Not so much. What happened to that other young woman who did not graduate from her journalism program because of a snafu over submitting the same work to two profs? These two need to hook up.
Reply

eeeradicator was starred eeeradicator was unstarred

MissNormaDesmond
07/08/09

@eeeradicator: What's that supposed to mean? If you're trying to say all college students cheat on assignments, no, they don't.
Reply

MissNormaDesmond was starred MissNormaDesmond was unstarred

Pope John Peeps II
07/08/09

In reply to Small Town Newspaper Intern Canned For Plagiarizing New York Times
That Talese interview sounds really, really made up. Like... seriously made up.
Reply

Pope John Peeps II was starred

raincoaster
07/08/09

@Pope John Peeps II: Agreed 100%. Too bad the blog's now private:

[hlmacarthur.wordpress.com]

Can't find anything on Google, but if I were at home with my stack of old Spy magazines, I'm relatively sure I'd find it somewhere in there, maybe with Henry Kissinger?
Reply

raincoaster was starred raincoaster was unstarred

Pope John Peeps II
07/08/09

@raincoaster: No I just think the whole interview itself is made up. Maybe for an assignment, maybe just for her own kicks. At best she had a couple of minutes with him on the phone.

But I've done a LOT of interviews, with a lot of people, and no one has ever "turned the tables" on me with personal, salacious questions. Especially not another professional.

And to use your interview to insinuate that Talese - who's married to the fabulous Nan Talese - is interested in you and suggests a "meet up" seem to me to be the height of egotism and asshole journalism. Making journalism touch on the personal is endearing in stories. I do it too. But then there's this bullshit, where the journalism becomes about you.

This is fake. The more I read it, the more I'm convinced it's absolutely fake.
Reply

Pope John Peeps II was starred

raincoaster
07/09/09

@Pope John Peeps II: Surely someone at Gawker who gets paid for this sort of thing could just PHONE Talese and ask?
Reply

raincoaster was starred raincoaster was unstarred

robrob9
07/08/09

In reply to Small Town Newspaper Intern Canned For Plagiarizing New York Times
Really? A whole post dedicated to the dismissal of an intern -- intern -- at some middling newspaper in Colorado. Really? And she's worthy of national humiliation ...why? Is this someone's ex-girlfriend at Gawker?

Cajun Boy, you're an asshole.
Reply

robrob9 was starred robrob9 was unstarred

robrob9
07/08/09

@robrob9: Okay, so, I just read her blog bio. Maybe a national frying pan to the face was in order after all. Still not totally convinced this merited the esteemed Gawker snarkification (you've got her sandwiched between items about Sarah Palin and Michael Jackson, for chrissakes), but that bio definitely makes me want to yell at her. If that was what pushed you over the edge to post this, well, I guess I can understand.

I'm sorry Ole Miss fired your dad.
Reply

robrob9 was starred robrob9 was unstarred

MissNormaDesmond
07/08/09

@robrob9: So if someone famous does something stupid and dishonest they should be grilled for it, but if someone unknown does it it's okay? I wouldn't accept that in reverse, so I don't know why I should accept it forwards. Being an intern is hardly an excuse for egregious plagiarism; grade school kids know you're not supposed to copy other people's work.
Reply

MissNormaDesmond was starred MissNormaDesmond was unstarred

TedSez
07/08/09

In reply to Small Town Newspaper Intern Canned For Plagiarizing New York Times
One of the passages she stole was from a writer's first-person account of what it was like when his own daughter died.

That's a level of wrongness beyond plagiarism, and beyond unforgivable.
Reply

TedSez was starred TedSez was unstarred

Richard Lawson
07/08/09

In reply to Small Town Newspaper Intern Canned For Plagiarizing New York Times
Gainesville and Colorado Springs? I'd start plagiarizing too if meant getting the hell out of those burgs.
Reply

Richard Lawson was starred Richard Lawson was unstarred

Satyrica
07/07/09

In reply to Small Town Newspaper Intern Canned For Plagiarizing New York Times
Pore, not pour.
Reply

Satyrica was starred Satyrica was unstarred

MissNormaDesmond
07/08/09

@Satyrica: Thank you.
Reply

MissNormaDesmond was starred MissNormaDesmond was unstarred

jorel845
07/07/09

In reply to Small Town Newspaper Intern Canned For Plagiarizing New York Times
Amazing how your digital footprint doesn't quite expire in equal measures.

She definitely can write, but the underwear bit is pathetic. Her savy is questionable, as she plagarised the NYT, and not something smaller and less well known.
Reply

jorel845 was starred jorel845 was unstarred

The Cajun Boy
07/07/09

@jorel845: I think you have to give her a bit of a pass for the underwear bit. She's young, a second-year student, and quite naive. She's obviously got some growing up to do.
Reply

The Cajun Boy was starred The Cajun Boy was unstarred

aLostLady
07/07/09

@The Cajun Boy: She hasn't grown out of the cutesy, I-think-I'm-being-refreshingly-honest-when-really-I'm-just-painting-a-half-naked-picture-of-my-cute-self-while-trying-to-play-journalist kind of thought process. Unless she thinks of herself as the next Carrie Bradshaw.

For the most part, her writing was brisk, showed a lot of personality, and was interesting. It's a shame she felt she had to lift from another publication.
Reply

aLostLady was starred aLostLady was unstarred

ThatMother-Chucker
07/08/09

@jorel845: Never have I ever... written about my underwear in J-School.

I don't care how cute you think you're being, or how young you are. Age shouldn't be a pass for an interview piece with serious gag factor. And anyone who gets into writing to be the next Carrie Bradshaw should quit now.
Reply

ThatMother-Chucker was starred

badass-boi
07/08/09

@ThatMother-Chucker: Not so fast chucker. This ain't your dad's journalism; writers and bloggers with colorful writing styles rule the day -- the 5 Ws and beat checks are dead. Before this cluster-chuck, she would have likely gone further playing the spunky, passionate, young writer than being a hard-bitten reliable newshound. Right? No. Realistic? You bet yur ass.
Reply

badass-boi was starred badass-boi was unstarred

snugbug
07/08/09

@jorel845: That was my thought, too: dilettante. Thus is not how you rip sh*t off. You grab a foot-tall stack of Playboys and Esquires from the 60s and 70s--where some of the most brilliant American long-form journalism or criticism ever has been published--and steal from there. Or lift off ideas for heds, ledes, etc. None of that stuff is archived online so it's practically untraceable these days. Plus, it's brilliant.
Reply

snugbug was starred snugbug was unstarred

raincoaster
07/08/09

@snugbug: Hey, hey I said it first! Look at the timestamp!
Reply

raincoaster was starred raincoaster was unstarred

raincoaster
07/07/09

In reply to Small Town Newspaper Intern Canned For Plagiarizing New York Times
Have you plugged the Talese interview into Google and seen if it matches up with a 10-year-old Playgirl interview with Tom Wolfe or something?
Reply

raincoaster was starred raincoaster was unstarred

Tremonius
07/07/09

In reply to Small Town Newspaper Intern Canned For Plagiarizing New York Times
Maybe they're the same homeless, who winter in Colorado Springs. Anyway, it's not Grand Theft, mere shoplifting.
Reply

Tremonius was starred Tremonius was unstarred

Earlier discussions Other discussions Show all discussions Show featured discussions only Start a new discussion

#haileymacarthur

Gawker

SUBSCRIBE TO Gawker

Small Town Newspaper Intern Canned For Plagiarizing New York Times

Login

Reset Password

Register

Submit Your Comment