Why isn't the group getting upset at the assholes who so excitedly signed up for this shit shack? Is is MTV's fault there is an entire group of people who dye their bodies orange, look up to the Gotti boys for style advice and think Jaegerbombs are da bomb? No! Im from LI, so this is more than familiar territory to me, but the fact these people lack enough awareness and irony is no fault but their own. Now, lets sit back and watch.
This show does not portray Italian Americans in a negative context so much as it is detrimental and harmful to the reputation of the State of New Jersey.
My father came over from Sicily when he was 12 and settled in a large Italian American community
(Hartford, CT) where my sister and I were raised. She and I both left the Northeast after college moving to two distinct and sizable U.S. cities, Pittsburgh, PA and Washington, DC. I cannot speak for Pittsburgh, which has an extensive and ingrained Italian American culture, but in Northern Virginia/DC the Italian American stereotype is usually an organized crime figure (either Godfather or Sopranos) and expressed jokingly.
The New Jersey stereotype however is a womanizing, spray on tanned, overly aggressive (on account of the steroids), uneducated, materialistic male drinking Heineken Light or Jaeger and complimented by a ridiculous blowout haircut.
This show does more to label the Garden State in an off-putting manner rather than Italian Americans at large. I predict that none of my co-workers, many that are originally from the Southeast and other parts of the United States, will watch this show and come off thinking that all Italians Americans are like this. Rather, they would be more inclined to believe that people from New Jersey act like this.
I recently lived in a very Irish neighborhood in the Bronx where there was an immigration center and a lot of just-off-the-boat Irish people. Almost every other building was a pub. On the other hand, the only time I'd ever seen it get violent was when I was in a pub where they were broadcasting a boxing match with some famous Irish boxer and at the same time, a fight broke out. But that could happen at any bar. My brother got mugged once, but it was by two Albanians.
My point is, as an Irish-American, I don't care about the Fighting Irish stereotypes because I know that there is some truth and that what isn't (or is no longer) true isn't worth protesting. And especially since The Departed came out, a lot of Irish-Americans even embrace those stereotypes, thinking it makes them look badass. For every Italian-American offended by the Godfather or the Sopranos or Real Housewives of New Jersey, there are even more who love that shit, like it gives them some power. Just live with it. That's what the Irish have done and that's what a lot of Jewish comedians have built their acts on. By embracing or even just tolerating the stereotypes, you reduce their power.
Everyone has someone in their family that embarrasses the ferg out of their people, as a whole. (If you can't think of anyone, then it's probably you.)
The answer may be to raise your kids not to turn into whatever douche-royale is depicted on the screen. Let it be a lesson to you, and stop the madness! It’s a PSA really.
@Spirit Fingers: Everyone has someone in their family that embarrasses the ferg out of their people, as a whole. (If you can't think of anyone, then it's probably you.)
Oh, if only a comment could be bronzed and mounted on the kitchen wall of every home right next to the standard woodcarving of the Last Supper...
In the end, they're behaving like most twentysomethings--only with more spray tan, hair products, steroids, and terrible fashion sense. The guido lifestyle was once the domain of lower class Italian-Americans using (what they considered) flash and violence to cover up poverty and/or ignorance. (Sound familiar?) Mall culture, MTV, and the cinematic portrayal of macho gangsters in television and film have spread the code to alot of other races at this point. Calling this a stereotype of just Italian-Americans is like calling Glee a stereotype of just gays.
I'm Italian, and, while I'm not in the "Oh my god! If people watch the Soprano's they'll think we're all involved in organized crime!" camp- mostly because I feel it's beneficial to have people think I could have them killed. But this show is just ridiculous. Oh my god! We all have bad tempers! We're hypersexual! We love hair products! We have big meals! We love our family! Oh! And we're really, really stupid. Like Tony Danza on Taxi.
@oudemia: Or, really, any Italian person on any show, ever. We're really only allowed to be wise in determining who is going to kill us or whom we should kill.
This show reminds me of the attempted BET show "Hot Ghetto Mess." People screamed bloody murder over the exploitation, but managed to overlook the show didn't create the culture it was mocking, nor did the culture cease to exist just because the show didn't happen.
I'm from Long Island, and this "type" does not discriminate. I've seen guys like this who are Italian, Irish, Puerto Rican, Jewish, and everything in between.
It's just sad when the ones who are balding try to do their hair like that. It's so...see-through.
I'm from the West Coast so NYNJ lingo is sort of unfamiliar. What exactly is a 'Guido' and/or a 'Benny'? And how does 'Goomba' figure in to all of this? Are they different names for the same thing?
@Fry_Bread_Power: Since everyone wants to curse everyone out Ill actually answer your question.
Guido was a slang term once on par with any of your typical racial remarks that morphed into a somewhat acceptable definition for people, typically of italian decent though not necessarily especially in the last decade or so, who acts like a goon. They typically use spray tan, gel their hair into spikes, and act like they are tough and hot shit.
A Benny (or a Shoobie as the real south Jersains call them) was a slang term for out of towners typically from the northern areas of New Jersey as well as NY who migrated to what they termed "the shore." the resort areas of NJ, for the summer.
The term stands for Bayonne, Elizabeth, Newark, and New York 3 of which where northern stops on the "Shore Line" which goes down to Bay Head NJ.
Shoobie typically is used south of Long Beach Island and is supposedly termed that because back in the 20s people used to carry their stuff for the beach in shoe boxes.
A goomba is a term for a "good old boy" want to be. Sometimes its used for actually connected people, but usually its just used on people who pretend they are.
Doesn't MTV rely on this formula? My Sweet 16: Obnoxious & rich 16 year olds. Laguna Beach: Obnoxious and rich high school kids from Cali. The City: Obnoxious and rich "socialites and hipsters" from NYC.
These are just obnoxious (and rich? haven't seen the show yet) people from the Jersey Shore.
If we're going to get upset it should be because MTV can't come up with a new fucking idea.
I'm 100% Italian (originally from Queens even!), and someone who grew up with this (my brother could probably be on this show AND my little cousin was actually considered for it when this was in development) let me tell you a few things.
1. This is what these people are really like. Maybe MTV turned the volume up to 11 for the show, but that didn't take much because guido volume is normally at around 9.5 in general (literally and figuratively).
2. The guidos will idolize this show. They have no sense of irony and genuinely don't get that people are making fun of them out of disgust and not jealousy. They do genuinely think they're super-awesome.
3. As someone who is personally about as far from this lifestyle as one can get (and worked hard to get there), I do have to say that I find the idea of this show both hilarious and painful at the same time. It's hilarious because yeah, they're idiots and its always fun to laugh at idiots. But honestly, I have to work SO hard in my life (especially my professional life) to actively distance myself from these stereotypes (which do follow me around, especially when I tell people I'm from Queens), that I really do cringe at the thought of even more people being exposed to this kind of behavior.
I mean, it's no worse than any other ethnic group really, but it just seems to be more significant because of all the pop culture surrounding the stereotypes.
11/25/09
11/25/09
My father came over from Sicily when he was 12 and settled in a large Italian American community
(Hartford, CT) where my sister and I were raised. She and I both left the Northeast after college moving to two distinct and sizable U.S. cities, Pittsburgh, PA and Washington, DC. I cannot speak for Pittsburgh, which has an extensive and ingrained Italian American culture, but in Northern Virginia/DC the Italian American stereotype is usually an organized crime figure (either Godfather or Sopranos) and expressed jokingly.
The New Jersey stereotype however is a womanizing, spray on tanned, overly aggressive (on account of the steroids), uneducated, materialistic male drinking Heineken Light or Jaeger and complimented by a ridiculous blowout haircut.
This show does more to label the Garden State in an off-putting manner rather than Italian Americans at large. I predict that none of my co-workers, many that are originally from the Southeast and other parts of the United States, will watch this show and come off thinking that all Italians Americans are like this. Rather, they would be more inclined to believe that people from New Jersey act like this.
11/25/09
My point is, as an Irish-American, I don't care about the Fighting Irish stereotypes because I know that there is some truth and that what isn't (or is no longer) true isn't worth protesting. And especially since The Departed came out, a lot of Irish-Americans even embrace those stereotypes, thinking it makes them look badass. For every Italian-American offended by the Godfather or the Sopranos or Real Housewives of New Jersey, there are even more who love that shit, like it gives them some power. Just live with it. That's what the Irish have done and that's what a lot of Jewish comedians have built their acts on. By embracing or even just tolerating the stereotypes, you reduce their power.
11/25/09
[www.getoffourisland.com]
11/25/09
[www.bennygohome.com]
11/25/09
It was the "Prostitution Whoo-rah!" heard around the world.
11/25/09
The answer may be to raise your kids not to turn into whatever douche-royale is depicted on the screen. Let it be a lesson to you, and stop the madness! It’s a PSA really.
11/25/09
Oh, if only a comment could be bronzed and mounted on the kitchen wall of every home right next to the standard woodcarving of the Last Supper...
11/25/09
11/25/09
11/25/09
11/25/09
11/25/09
11/25/09
[www.bennygohome.com]
11/25/09
It's just sad when the ones who are balding try to do their hair like that. It's so...see-through.
11/25/09
11/25/09
Guido was a slang term once on par with any of your typical racial remarks that morphed into a somewhat acceptable definition for people, typically of italian decent though not necessarily especially in the last decade or so, who acts like a goon. They typically use spray tan, gel their hair into spikes, and act like they are tough and hot shit.
A Benny (or a Shoobie as the real south Jersains call them) was a slang term for out of towners typically from the northern areas of New Jersey as well as NY who migrated to what they termed "the shore." the resort areas of NJ, for the summer.
The term stands for Bayonne, Elizabeth, Newark, and New York 3 of which where northern stops on the "Shore Line" which goes down to Bay Head NJ.
Shoobie typically is used south of Long Beach Island and is supposedly termed that because back in the 20s people used to carry their stuff for the beach in shoe boxes.
A goomba is a term for a "good old boy" want to be. Sometimes its used for actually connected people, but usually its just used on people who pretend they are.
11/25/09
11/25/09
11/25/09
These are just obnoxious (and rich? haven't seen the show yet) people from the Jersey Shore.
If we're going to get upset it should be because MTV can't come up with a new fucking idea.
11/25/09
1. This is what these people are really like. Maybe MTV turned the volume up to 11 for the show, but that didn't take much because guido volume is normally at around 9.5 in general (literally and figuratively).
2. The guidos will idolize this show. They have no sense of irony and genuinely don't get that people are making fun of them out of disgust and not jealousy. They do genuinely think they're super-awesome.
3. As someone who is personally about as far from this lifestyle as one can get (and worked hard to get there), I do have to say that I find the idea of this show both hilarious and painful at the same time. It's hilarious because yeah, they're idiots and its always fun to laugh at idiots. But honestly, I have to work SO hard in my life (especially my professional life) to actively distance myself from these stereotypes (which do follow me around, especially when I tell people I'm from Queens), that I really do cringe at the thought of even more people being exposed to this kind of behavior.
I mean, it's no worse than any other ethnic group really, but it just seems to be more significant because of all the pop culture surrounding the stereotypes.
11/25/09