• Profile logout login

#kimberlydenisemunley#faithanddoubtaspx

Gawker

Share Cancel
   
Upload an image | Add an image URL
×

logging in
  • FAQ. Include # before tag:
  • #tips,
  • #stalker,
  • #opencaption,
  • #internalmemos,
  • etc.

New York, 8:16 AM
Wed Nov 25
49 posts in the last 24 hours

Team

Tip Your Editors:
tips@gawker.com
Tipline: 646-214-8138

Editor-in-Chief:
Gabriel Snyder | Email

West Coast Editor:
Richard Rushfield | Email

Contributing Editors:

Valleywag:
Ryan Tate | Email

Media:
Hamilton Nolan | Email

Politics:
Alex Pareene | Email

Investigations:
John Cook | Email

Entertainment:
Brian Moylan | Email

Nights:
Adrian Chen | Email
Azaria Jagger | Email
Ravi Somaiya | Email

Weekends:
Foster Kamer | Email

Video Editor:
Richard Blakeley | Email

SUBSCRIBE TO Gawker RSS

New: Breaking news and daily top stories via email
4260 Subscribers
Gawker
  • Your version of Internet Explorer is not supported. Please upgrade to the most recent version in order to view comments.

    Dsmvwl  Admin  Promote to frontpage Approve user Ban user ×
    Image of Uncle_Billy_Slumming Uncle_Billy_Slumming
    11/12/09

    In reply to Who Really Shot the Fort Hood Shooter?
    This just in: Sully and Munley spotted at a dive in D.C., getting blitzed. #kimberlydenisemunley
     Reply
    Uncle_Billy_Slumming was starred Uncle_Billy_Slumming was unstarred
    Image of New Gonzo Drifter New Gonzo Drifter
    11/12/09

    @Uncle_Billy_Slumming: HA, ha, ha ... #kimberlydenisemunley
     Reply
    New Gonzo Drifter was starred New Gonzo Drifter was unstarred
    Image of Uncle_Billy_Slumming Uncle_Billy_Slumming
    11/12/09

    @New Gonzo Drifter: That comment was really inappropriate, Larry. #kimberlydenisemunley
     Reply
    Uncle_Billy_Slumming was starred Uncle_Billy_Slumming was unstarred
    Image of New Gonzo Drifter New Gonzo Drifter
    11/12/09

    @Uncle_Billy_Slumming: You should take your material to TDS and try to get on as a writer ... #kimberlydenisemunley
     Reply
    New Gonzo Drifter was starred New Gonzo Drifter was unstarred
    Image of Uncle_Billy_Slumming Uncle_Billy_Slumming
    11/12/09

    @New Gonzo Drifter:

    ...but.... I've seen that show... they're funny all the time. My stupid little jokes are only funny after you've had a couple of Bong-Water Tinctures #kimberlydenisemunley
     Reply
    Uncle_Billy_Slumming was starred Uncle_Billy_Slumming was unstarred
    Image of New Gonzo Drifter New Gonzo Drifter
    11/12/09

    @Uncle_Billy_Slumming: I just got the willies thinking about taking a big slug from that cup o' nasty. I prefer my tokes a la the real green stuff ... #kimberlydenisemunley
     Reply
    New Gonzo Drifter was starred New Gonzo Drifter was unstarred
    Image of Trai_Dep Trai_Dep
    11/12/09

    In reply to Who Really Shot the Fort Hood Shooter?
    Where there was a cynical, Goebbelesque motivation (which the Army and the WH eagerly seized upon) with Lynch, I'm more inclined to give any discrepancies in this case the benefit of a doubt. Taking one for the team is heroic enough; there's no need to gild the lily with Munley. And firefights are rife with honestly confused witnesses.
    ...Criminal charges should have been filed in the Lynch case, however. #kimberlydenisemunley
     Reply
    Trai_Dep was starred Trai_Dep was unstarred
    Image of Trai_Dep Trai_Dep
    11/12/09

    @Trai_Dep: And, of course, this will be sorted out in time, once the bullets are traced back to the guns that fired them. #kimberlydenisemunley
     Reply
    Trai_Dep was starred Trai_Dep was unstarred
    Image of topsy topsy
    11/12/09

    In reply to Who Really Shot the Fort Hood Shooter?
    SURPRISE!! Except, not. This isn't the first time a story has been 'whitewashed'. The real story,' black man with gun puts down brown man with gun', wouldn't have played as well on the media. Munley was a very convenient symbol; plucky, little white protects us all from the dark Islamic threat. Acknowledging the man who REALLY saved the day doesn't take a way a fraction from Munley's heroism. It just sets the record straight. #kimberlydenisemunley
     Reply
    topsy was starred topsy was unstarred
    Image of BoKnowsMagic BoKnowsMagic
    11/12/09

    @topsy: The little white with pluck still took one for America. Let's not forget that! #kimberlydenisemunley
     Reply
    topsy promoted this comment BoKnowsMagic was starred BoKnowsMagic was unstarred
    Image of topsy topsy
    11/12/09

    @BoKnowsMagic: You need to read my comment again. #kimberlydenisemunley
     Reply
    topsy was starred topsy was unstarred
    Image of BoKnowsMagic BoKnowsMagic
    11/12/09

    @topsy: And? #kimberlydenisemunley
     Reply
    BoKnowsMagic was starred BoKnowsMagic was unstarred
    Image of TheBusinessGuy TheBusinessGuy
    11/12/09

    In reply to Who Really Shot the Fort Hood Shooter?
    Does this mean there will be a do-over of last week's women-in-combat post? #kimberlydenisemunley
     Reply
    TheBusinessGuy was starred TheBusinessGuy was unstarred
    Image of TheBusinessGuy TheBusinessGuy
    11/12/09

    @TheBusinessGuy: Whoops. I missed tripletheat's post below, which essentially made the same point. Sorry. #kimberlydenisemunley
     Reply
    TheBusinessGuy was starred TheBusinessGuy was unstarred
    Image of New Gonzo Drifter New Gonzo Drifter
    11/12/09

    @TheBusinessGuy: I hope so. That was a multi-day duel to the death. #kimberlydenisemunley
     Reply
    New Gonzo Drifter was starred New Gonzo Drifter was unstarred
    Image of Steverino Begins Steverino Begins
    11/12/09

    In reply to Who Really Shot the Fort Hood Shooter?
    We need to resolve this so Gail knows who she's role-playing tonight with Oprah. #kimberlydenisemunley
     Reply
    Steverino Begins was starred Steverino Begins was unstarred
    Image of econdave econdave
    11/12/09

    In reply to Who Really Shot the Fort Hood Shooter?
    The woman who shot Major Hasan, she shot Major Hasan/
    She was the bravest of them all. #kimberlydenisemunley
     Reply
    econdave was starred econdave was unstarred
    Image of Flashman Flashman
    11/12/09

    In reply to Who Really Shot the Fort Hood Shooter?
    This could easily be solved by a public vote.
    Oprah should rig up two different 1-888 numbers so the people can decide if they want some black guy to be the hero, or the nice blonde white lady. #kimberlydenisemunley
     Reply
    Flashman was starred Flashman was unstarred
    Image of triplethreat triplethreat
    11/12/09

    In reply to Who Really Shot the Fort Hood Shooter?
    "Much media frothing about Munley "--including like 4 Gawker posts! A little self-awareness? #kimberlydenisemunley
     Reply
    triplethreat was starred triplethreat was unstarred
    Image of Glib and Bitchy Glib and Bitchy
    11/12/09

    In reply to Who Really Shot the Fort Hood Shooter?
    Sgt. Todd told his story to the AP last weekend [news.yahoo.com] and I was a little surprised it didn't get more play, but it seemed then there would be room for more than one hero in this case. His story seems to dovetail decently with the witness' (although questions certainly remain). For example, Todd says Munley was down by the time he arrived and shot Hasan.
    But who shot whom is something ballistics should be able to figure out, right?
    [gawker.com]
     Reply
    Edited by Glib and Bitchy at 11/12/09 8:59 AM Glib and Bitchy was starred Glib and Bitchy was unstarred
    Image of TheUptightMidwesterner TheUptightMidwesterner
    11/12/09

    In reply to Who Really Shot the Fort Hood Shooter?
    I actually watched this episode of Oprah, and it seemed like Munley was very humble and kind of uncomfortable. Oprah was really looking for some inspirational story from them and they were fairly matter-of-fact about it.
    For instance, Oprah thought a stock photo of Sgt. Munley carrying a rifle was taken that day, and the Sgt had to correct Oprah and say, no, that picture was taken years ago during a training excercise. #kimberlydenisemunley
     Reply
    TheUptightMidwesterner was starred TheUptightMidwesterner was unstarred
    Image of skt.smth skt.smth
    11/12/09

    In reply to Who Really Shot the Fort Hood Shooter?
    None of this would matter if we (no wait, the media) weren't always so quick to create hero narratives in the first place. #kimberlydenisemunley
     Reply
    skt.smth was starred skt.smth was unstarred
    Image of britneyspearstears britneyspearstears
    11/12/09

    @skt.smth: Agreed. Anyone over the age of 12 who still has a hero, is a damn fool. #kimberlydenisemunley
     Reply
    britneyspearstears was starred britneyspearstears was unstarred
    Image of Novaload Novaload
    11/12/09

    In reply to Who Really Shot the Fort Hood Shooter?
    Ah, the notorious "unnamed witness"--and by all means, let's focus on this instead of Hasan and the morons who let him slip through the system again and again because they were afraid to make a negative comment about a Muslim. #kimberlydenisemunley
     Reply
    Novaload was starred Novaload was unstarred
    Image of Mediahohoho Mediahohoho
    11/12/09

    @Novaload: I'm so glad the lesson we're all going to learn from this wretched incident is it's okay to say bad things about Muslims. #kimberlydenisemunley
     Reply
    Mediahohoho was starred Mediahohoho was unstarred
    Image of Novaload Novaload
    11/12/09

    @Mediahohoho: Yes; that would be a very important lesson, that political correctness--as revealed by the sources at Walter Reed--interfered with honest judgment. #kimberlydenisemunley
     Reply
    Novaload was starred Novaload was unstarred
    Image of skt.smth skt.smth
    11/12/09

    @Novaload: Here's the problem. All this line of inquiry essentially leads to is the argument that non-Anglo, particularly Muslim, soldiers should be deemed immediately untrustworthy until proven otherwise. Because to the xenophobes who follow this line of inquiry, no matter what the circumstances surrounding events like this, there will always be a scrap of information, something overheard, something "intuited" by somebody, that would have tipped people off had they not been so bent on political correctness. This will always be the narrative in the case of a non-Anglo who goes over the edge and pulls a stunt like this.

    So somebody could have said something. So what? How do you rectify it? How do you move ahead in the future? I'd really love to hear your idea for a new regime. #kimberlydenisemunley
     Reply
    skt.smth was starred skt.smth was unstarred
    Image of Adah Adah
    11/12/09

    @skt.smth: I don't think that's necessarily the case, that the one question leads to out-of-control xenophobia. There appear to have been several documented instances where Hasan acted or spoke in a way that caused alarm wtih his superiors. The actions caused this speculation - not Hasan's ethnicity. It is a legitimate question to ask, if Hasan's ethnicity and religious background prevented the military from discharging him. You can ask this without asking if all Muslim service members currently in good standing should be discharged.

    [www.latimes.com]
     Reply
    Novaload promoted this comment Edited by Adah at 11/12/09 8:10 AM Adah was starred Adah was unstarred
    Image of Han Valen Han Valen
    11/12/09

    @skt.smth: How about this: USE COMMON SENSE.

    If someone (particularly an army officer) is mouthing off some kind of insane jihadi rant to anyone who will sit still for five minutes, your common sense should tell you that, hey, maybe this guy doesn't belong in the armed forces.

    Please note how this is different from considering 'all muslims' guilty until proven innocent. And if some of their fellow soldiers are overzealous and Muslims feel like they're being over-scrutinized in general, well, tough shit. They should blame the lunatics who are actually committing these atrocities for giving them a bad name, not the people who are just trying to protect themselves. I'd much rather hurt some feelings than actually, you know, get a bunch of people killed. #kimberlydenisemunley
     Reply
    Novaload promoted this comment Han Valen was starred Han Valen was unstarred
    Image of flugennock flugennock
    11/12/09

    @skt.smth: The Muslims-Are-Evil consiracists have already got this in their teeth, shaking it vigorously like a neurotic dog.

    That windbag Joe Scarborough was on MSNBC this morning with some guy from Time -- pimping a big feature story in Time, of course -- regurgitating that whole "he sneaked up in the ranks because of PC" line of bullshit, with Scarborough nodding in enthusiastic approval, to my complete lack of surprise.

    Meanwhile, all these yahoos have completely -- and conveniently -- forgotten about Timothy McVeigh, a good, upstanding White Christian gentleman. #kimberlydenisemunley
     Reply
    New Gonzo Drifter promoted this comment flugennock was starred flugennock was unstarred
    Image of no I said no I won't no no I said no I won't no
    11/12/09

    @skt.smth: No, actually, it leads to the argument that the right and left hands of government need to be able to talk to one another, and that political correctness or outsized sensitivities shouldn't be allowed to win out over common sense and appropriate action. Read the NPR report out yesterday; this guy should have been out of the military a long time ago, and the security concerns about him should have been shared and acted upon much more effectively. #kimberlydenisemunley
     Reply
    Novaload promoted this comment no I said no I won't no was starred no I said no I won't no was unstarred
    Image of no I said no I won't no no I said no I won't no
    11/12/09

    @flugennock: McVeigh was not ever considered good or upstanding or a gentleman. No recollection whether he was considered a good Christian. White, I'll give you. #kimberlydenisemunley
     Reply
    New Gonzo Drifter promoted this comment no I said no I won't no was starred no I said no I won't no was unstarred
    Image of New Gonzo Drifter New Gonzo Drifter
    11/12/09

    @no I said no I won't no: McVeigh was a war "hero" before carrying out his acts ... in that regard, in his community, to the people who knew him -- his superiors, etc, he WAS an "upstanding" citizen -- maybe you're not old enough to remember the shock of a decorated and honorably-discharged war veteran (awarded the Bronze Star) carrying out the worst act of domestic terrorism TO DATE at that time?

    But yeah, in the end he was a scumbag. #kimberlydenisemunley
     Reply
    New Gonzo Drifter was starred New Gonzo Drifter was unstarred
    Image of Niko Bellic Niko Bellic
    11/12/09

    @Novaload: political correctness...interfered with honest judgment.

    You are confusing political correctness with racism. If I give a free pass to someone based on his race/ethnicity/religion, it's not called "political correctness". It's called racism. Politically correct would be to ignore the person's religion and ethnicity.

    Allowing Hasan to stay in the military, just because he is Muslim, even though he was showing hostility towards the military and it's actions, is simply - racism.
     Reply
    Edited by Niko Bellic at 11/12/09 10:51 AM Niko Bellic was starred Niko Bellic was unstarred
    Image of Novaload Novaload
    11/12/09

    @Adah: Well said. See, skt.smth thinks that if you criticize ONE person, you are criticizing them ALL. That's a slippery slope fallacy, or possibly an extreme hasty generalization, also a fallacy. #kimberlydenisemunley
     Reply
    Novaload was starred Novaload was unstarred
    Image of Novaload Novaload
    11/12/09

    @flugennock: Maybe you should read the Walter Reed reports where that was exactly the line: It would look bad if we fired a Muslim, we have so few of them.
    Tokenism and PC-ness at their worst.
    Timothy McVeigh is apples/oranges--I don't recall anyone considering him a good, upstanding ANYTHING--sources, please? Or are you just clearing out your blowhole? #kimberlydenisemunley
     Reply
    Novaload was starred Novaload was unstarred
    Image of Iconoclastodon Iconoclastodon
    11/12/09

    @Novaload: I doubt it was simply because Hasan was a Muslim. When I was in the Army (still in the 2000s) there was a culture of extreme reluctance to do anything but give positive performance reviews to young officers. This was because to do so would start a long, tiring battle, and effectively end the officer's career as well. So, you passed the officer along to the next unit. All this talk about how Hasan was reviewed well and advanced from unit to unit despite concerns about his performance and his sanity (!) sounds awfully familiar to me. #kimberlydenisemunley
     Reply
    Novaload promoted this comment Iconoclastodon was starred Iconoclastodon was unstarred
    Image of Niko Bellic Niko Bellic
    11/12/09

    @Novaload: It would look bad if we fired a Muslim, we have so few of them. Tokenism and PC-ness at their worst.

    For fuck's sake. It's racism, get that into your ignorant head. #kimberlydenisemunley
     Reply
    Niko Bellic was starred Niko Bellic was unstarred
    Image of no I said no I won't no no I said no I won't no
    11/12/09

    @New Gonzo Drifter: Alas, I am quite old enough to remember all of these things. But a few points: yes, he was awarded the Bronze Star and was a top gunner - no question that for a point in his life he did well at what he was asked to do. However, he was never an officer, he failed to make the Special Forces, and after discharge (nearly everyone is honorably discharged) worked crap jobs and drifted. He became a deadbeat gambler, tax scofflaw and spent his time at gun shows and writing stupid letters to the editor. Assume he'd never done what he ultimately did, and no one would consider him a fine, upstanding Christian gentleman or citizen.

    And ftr, he was Catholic, which, while of course Christian, doesn't neatly fit into the "crazy cracker evangelical" meme people like to throw around. #kimberlydenisemunley
     Reply
    no I said no I won't no was starred no I said no I won't no was unstarred
    Image of Novaload Novaload
    11/12/09

    @Niko Bellic: I was trying to be polite. I guess we need another word, though, since "Muslim" isn't a race. "Preferential treatment based on..." maybe... #kimberlydenisemunley
     Reply
    Novaload was starred Novaload was unstarred
    Image of Novaload Novaload
    11/12/09

    @Niko Bellic: See above. "Muslim" isn't a race. #kimberlydenisemunley
     Reply
    Novaload was starred Novaload was unstarred
    Image of Novaload Novaload
    11/12/09

    @Iconoclastodon: Oh, no doubt; this is a well known principle, a.k.a. "Sh*t rises." And it's true, some people pointed out the bureaucracy involved in trying to fire someone. But in this case, his religious background was also an issue. #kimberlydenisemunley
     Reply
    Novaload was starred Novaload was unstarred
    Image of Niko Bellic Niko Bellic
    11/12/09

    @Novaload: Ok, we may need another word. But it sure as hell is not "political correctness". It is the exact opposite of it.

    It really irks me whenever I sense that people try to discredit political correctness by slapping the label of it onto a bad behavior (call it racism or ethnicism or religionism or whatever) which involves preferential treatment of minorities.

    Calling these incidents "political correctness ran amok" is the same as calling a situation where when you are forced to play by the rules, but someone else breaks them - "playing by the rules ran amok". It smacks of your trying to discredit playing by the rules all together (because you know that in that case you'd have the upper hand).

    There is nothing wrong with political correctness. It cannot run amok (except maybe when considering style in creative writing). It's a good thing. Stop calling bad things "political correctness at its worst" where they have nothing to do with it. #kimberlydenisemunley
     Reply
    Niko Bellic was starred Niko Bellic was unstarred
    Image of New Gonzo Drifter New Gonzo Drifter
    11/12/09

    @no I said no I won't no: Um, as a former enlisted type, I fail to see why you have pointed out that McVeigh wasn't an officer. So, what, enlisted troops aren't as good?

    And on the failure of his ability to make into SF -- 70% of those who go out for SF, on average, don't make it. That's fairly normal -- not to make it, that is (at least on the first go 'round).

    You also failed to note that he was initially generally discharged -- it was later that he was given the honorable discharge. And I know about nearly everyone being given an honorable discharge, as I was, myself, honorably discharged. I'm savvy on the procedures.

    I'm not defending McVeigh, but I think you lack a little info.

    Also, did you know that two thirds of homeless men are military veterans ... it is not uncommon for vets to get out and drift -- especially for the enlisted ranks who did not get the G.I. Bill. They often float from one wage-earning job to the next.

    It almost sounds like you're calling all enlisted types who get out of the military and don't have white-collar jobs waiting on them losers. You're not, but it sure seems like you are very uppity about yourself and your perception of enlisted vets ... I'd bet you were a former officer and probably bought into all that "we-are-better-than-the-enlisted-types" garbage.

    Um, and do you know how many right-wing crazy vets are buying arms now-a-days? Your point about McVeigh attending mass gun shows is now uncommon, ESPECIALLY for vets, regardless of whether their service was as an officer or in the enlisted ranks.

    I don't give two sh**s about Christian stuff as most Christians are idiot numb nuts. #kimberlydenisemunley
     Reply
    New Gonzo Drifter was starred New Gonzo Drifter was unstarred
    Image of britneyspearstears britneyspearstears
    11/12/09

    @Novaload: There is but one race: Human. #kimberlydenisemunley
     Reply
    britneyspearstears was starred britneyspearstears was unstarred
    Image of New Gonzo Drifter New Gonzo Drifter
    11/12/09

    @New Gonzo Drifter: I mean to say, in my second to last para, that vets attending gun shows is NOT uncommon ... apologies for any confusion in that sentence. #kimberlydenisemunley
     Reply
    New Gonzo Drifter was starred New Gonzo Drifter was unstarred
    Image of Motoko Kusanagi Motoko Kusanagi
    11/12/09

    @skt.smth: Well, you could say that...or you could say that the lesson here is that it's OK to call a duck a duck. #kimberlydenisemunley
     Reply
    Motoko Kusanagi was starred Motoko Kusanagi was unstarred
    Image of Mediahohoho Mediahohoho
    11/12/09

    @Novaload: Yes, but first you'll have to wrest control of the Army out of the grip of the Liberals who have controlled it for two centuries now, filling its ranks with slaves to political correctness.

    Or maybe, as has been suggested elsewhere in this thread, it was a combination of bureaucratic laziness and sheer stupidity, not an unheard of combination at Reed--or in the military in general--from what I understand.

    But that doesn't allow conservatives to triumphantly ascribe this to a "liberal" bugaboo that liberals don't actually subscribe to any more than do conservatives (see: platitudes regarding the Iraq War c. 2003 - present).

    If, however, we're going to purge the militatry, I'd much we did so based on officers' approval of religiously inspired violence, starting with in-depth interviews of the fans of Scott Reoder, among others. #kimberlydenisemunley
     Reply
    Mediahohoho was starred Mediahohoho was unstarred
    Image of Novaload Novaload
    11/12/09

    @britneyspearstears: So does that make the Aryan Brotherhood humanists? #kimberlydenisemunley
     Reply
    Novaload was starred Novaload was unstarred
    Image of Novaload Novaload
    11/12/09

    @Niko Bellic: I think there is a second, and negative, use or meaning of "PC"--i.e., "political correct" = saying what you "should" say by changeable modern standards at the moment vs "what is right,"-- so it's what a politician or other person says to avoid drawing criticism. So "politically correct" is weaker than just "correct." #kimberlydenisemunley
     Reply
    Novaload was starred Novaload was unstarred
    Image of Novaload Novaload
    11/12/09

    @Mediahohoho: No, but it's a interesting point and I think the conservatives actually draw more power and interest from people for at least stating --though extremely-- what multicultural-diversity-we-judge-no-one will never say. The rush to judgment here was the apologists who asserted right away, "Oh, this didn't have anything to do with his being a Muslim; and of course Islam is a religion without violence that loves infidels etc etc. And so what if he contacted the 9/11 cleric 20 times, that doesn't mean anything." They were releasing statements like that instantly, when people only knew his name. #kimberlydenisemunley
     Reply
    Novaload was starred Novaload was unstarred
    Image of Mediahohoho Mediahohoho
    11/12/09

    @Novaload: I am intrigued by the identities of these apologists of which you speak. Perhaps we watch and read different media, but I don't recall anyone I saw, heard or read quoted having anywhere near the reaction you describe. Granted, it would make a spectacular straw man argument to just make up the statement you put between quotation marks, but I'll just assume that you pulled that from a reputable source quoting a leading spokesperson for the multicultural-diversity-we-judge-no-one coalition which, though I've never heard of it before, I'm sure exists. Because what repulses me almost as much as the act itself are the people using it to score political points. That's just disgusting. #kimberlydenisemunley
     Reply
    Mediahohoho was starred Mediahohoho was unstarred
    Image of britneyspearstears britneyspearstears
    11/12/09

    @Novaload: No. #kimberlydenisemunley
     Reply
    britneyspearstears was starred britneyspearstears was unstarred
    Image of no I said no I won't no no I said no I won't no
    11/12/09

    @New Gonzo Drifter: I apologize if the way I phrased the point about his being enlisted implied I was suggesting that was evidence of his not being a good person or that enlisted isn't a fine thing to be. Absolutely not intended. I was intending to make a point countering the notion that he was considered fine and upstanding, but I didn't articulate the point well. I am a huge military fan and supporter.

    I grew up military, so I'm familiar. And you're right - there's a lot of division between officers and enlisted that was to me, even as a child, uncomfortable and wrong in many ways.

    The whole point, though, was that McVeigh was not considered a "gentleman" or by any accounts a fine or particularly Christian person, which is what was originally asserted. After he distinguished himself in combat, he went on neither to achieve in the military or out of it. Your comment that he was initially given a general, rather than honorable discharge, underscores my point. I don't consider his track post-military to be representative or typical of military; he appeared to follow a much worse path and he ultimately, of course, did. So, back to the original comment, I don't think a lot of the "yahoos" considered McVeigh to be a shining example of anything, before or after he murdered people. #kimberlydenisemunley
     Reply
    no I said no I won't no was starred no I said no I won't no was unstarred
    Image of Novaload Novaload
    11/12/09

    @Mediahohoho: The commander/speaker at the base said this at the very outset. And then on the Sunday morning talk shows, CBS in particular, there were senators leaping up to make this point: Nothing to do with Islam.
    The FBI was trying this spin, today too, to account for their dismissal of at least 20 emails to the radical 9/11 cleric--because if you allow that he might have been an religious extremist, then our multi-billion dollar homeland security system failed us big time. Far better to just say he was a "nut." #kimberlydenisemunley
     Reply
    Novaload was starred Novaload was unstarred
    Image of New Gonzo Drifter New Gonzo Drifter
    11/12/09

    @no I said no I won't no: Hey, thanks for the clarification. And I didn't mean to blow too hard at you ... you can understand the sensitivities. Cheers. #kimberlydenisemunley
     Reply
    New Gonzo Drifter was starred New Gonzo Drifter was unstarred
    Image of skt.smth skt.smth
    11/12/09

    @Motoko Kusanagi: And what are the limits? Exactly how compelling does our information need to be in order to justify "calling a duck a duck"? What the right-wingers are seizing on right now is a supposedly "chilling" presentation made by Hasan in which he detailed the "Koranic" mindset of fundamentalist Muslims and warned that they could, in fact, infiltrate the military and engage in terrorist acts from within. So because a Muslim dude makes this presentation, we're supposed to have known that he was talking about himself, and then what? Discharge him from the military? Imprison him? What's your solution? #kimberlydenisemunley
     Reply
    skt.smth was starred skt.smth was unstarred
    Image of skt.smth skt.smth
    11/12/09

    @Han Valen: What rant was there? The dude was doing a presentation on awareness of the potential for Muslim extremists to infiltrate the army. That he had any ulterior motive, or that he was "tipping off" the brass about what he was going to do, seems like just another case of hindsight being 20/20. It is, after all, not exactly weird for a Muslim to do a presentation about issues of Islam in the military.

    I just love how this narrative implies that military brass sat idly by, knowing that this dude was going to kill tons of soldiers, but they were so paralyzed by political correctness that they couldn't muster the balls to do anything. Do you people really effing believe that? If so, wow. I'm blown away by the lengths some people will go to--even using the tragic deaths of service members--to forward a xenophobic agenda.

    Of course, the one thing you people will never say is how the rules should be changed, on a very specific level, to combat this type of situation, to make sure that it never happens again. Because then you'd be forced to lay out your cards and reveal your bigotry. #kimberlydenisemunley
     Reply
    skt.smth was starred skt.smth was unstarred
    Image of skt.smth skt.smth
    11/12/09

    @Adah: Question ... when did his actions "cause alarm"? At the time of, or in hindsight? We've heard this narrative over and over again--in crimes committed by both whites and minorities--that "there was something weird," or that "there were clear warning signs." But do we honestly believe that these military officials essentially knew that Hasan would shoot up a military base, and decided because of PC-ness not to do anything about it, to just let it happen? And if they didn't know that this would happen, then why are we laying on the speculative nonsense? They either knew and did nothing to stop it, or they didn't know it would happen and simply were caught up in a scenario that would have played out anyway.

    At the end of the day, we don't have jihadis shooting up our military bases every day. When was the last time something like this happened again? Please, let's get some perspective people. #kimberlydenisemunley
     Reply
    skt.smth was starred skt.smth was unstarred
    Image of Novaload Novaload
    11/12/09

    @skt.smth: Do you know what Medical Grand Rounds are? Did you read the slide show? It's available. It was so inappropriate that other Muslims in the audience raised their hands to point out that many Muslims do not embrace fundamentalist, extremist beliefs. And people openly wondered if he was going to end up shooting his comrades. It was inappropriate for Grand Rounds and inappropriate as a "religious" presentation. You should check your facts before you accuse us of "bigotry" -- because you are arguing from a position of ignorance. It's just possible that some Muslims, including Major Hasan, are extremists; and some are terrorists. Walter Reed wanted to get rid of him because he was a poor performer and increasingly caught up in his religion. He contacted the 9/11 cleric 20 times. He shot and killed unarmed people. He clearly planned not leaving there alive. That's a suicide attack because he (said he) did not want to kill other Muslims.
    So we're bigoted because? #kimberlydenisemunley
     Reply
    Novaload was starred Novaload was unstarred
    Image of skt.smth skt.smth
    11/12/09

    @Novaload: What's bigoted is not the reaction, in hindsight, that this was an act born of fundamentalism. What's bigoted is where the conversation goes after that, and where, clearly, you are worried it will go because of that fact. Again, what do you propose should be done in order to make sure that Muslim extremists can never perpetrate something like this again? Should "religious extremism" be the basis for dismissal from the military? If so, how do we define "religious extremism"? It may have been simple to do that with Hasan, but it won't always be so simple. In fact, such a clear case, if it's as clear as you believe it to be, will tend to be the exception, not the rule. Again, I find it difficult to believe that everybody in the room thought that Hasan would kill fellow soldiers, and yet they did nothing about it because they were paralyzed by political correctness. In the military? You have to be absolutely kidding me. Military brass perpetrate/cover up far more grotesque improprieties than discharging (supposedly) clearly extremist threats from their ranks. On like, a daily basis. I don't buy that "everybody knew" he was going to pull this shit. It's textbook handwringing/ass-covering of the highest order.

    Also, what are we going to do about the well-documented Christian extremism that pervades in the Armed Forces? I'm sure we won't hear anything about that from the anti-Muslim xenophobes. #kimberlydenisemunley
     Reply
    skt.smth was starred skt.smth was unstarred
    Image of skt.smth skt.smth
    11/12/09

    @Novaload: Nice passive-aggressiveness there. What I'm saying is that the outrage surrounding Hasan has led for people to reassess the systems by which people are selected, allowed entry, and permitted to continue in the Armed Forces. Which clearly means that the implications will, yes, be felt by others who are not Hasan. What I'm wondering is exactly what these countermeasures against another event of the same type happening would be. All we hear, over and over again, is that this was a problem of political correctness, and that we need to be able to "call something what it is." Well, what does that mean in concrete terms, not just for Hasan, but for anybody who might be even remotely like Hasan (in behavior, not necessarily race/religion)? #kimberlydenisemunley
     Reply
    skt.smth was starred skt.smth was unstarred
    Image of skt.smth skt.smth
    11/12/09

    @Novaload: And of course, you will never say what the specific antidote to "multicultural-diversity-we-judge-no-one" is. All you can do is sit back and snipe, because you know that speaking whatever vile thought is on your mind is verboten. #kimberlydenisemunley
     Reply
    skt.smth was starred skt.smth was unstarred
    Image of Motoko Kusanagi Motoko Kusanagi
    11/13/09

    @skt.smth: Being Muslim has nothing to do with it. If he was Korean, say, or Jewish, it would be the same. Now, please get over yourself. #kimberlydenisemunley
     Reply
    Motoko Kusanagi was starred Motoko Kusanagi was unstarred
    Image of skt.smth skt.smth
    11/13/09

    @Motoko Kusanagi: Really? Then why are Christian extremists and Neo-Nazis allowed to remain in the military? #kimberlydenisemunley
     Reply
    skt.smth was starred skt.smth was unstarred
    Image of GitEmSteveDave_ForgotNametag GitEmSteveDave_ForgotNametag
    11/12/09

    In reply to Who Really Shot the Fort Hood Shooter?
    If we've learned anything from CSI, some dummies with some laser pointers and some ballistic matches will clear this up, but only after taking off your sunglasses to the strains of a Who song. #kimberlydenisemunley
     Reply
    GitEmSteveDave_ForgotNametag was starred GitEmSteveDave_ForgotNametag was unstarred
    Image of Brad Brown Brad Brown
    11/12/09

    @GitEmSteveDave_IsSlacking: However, if we've learned anything from years of listening to Michael Savage, we know that the Obama administration will force those dummies to forge their results, thus making it appear that the young woman was the sole hero. Also, there will be a mysterious death; I will go out on a limb and guess that it will be Sgt. Mark Todd. #kimberlydenisemunley
     Reply
    Brad Brown was starred Brad Brown was unstarred
    Image of GitEmSteveDave_ForgotNametag GitEmSteveDave_ForgotNametag
    11/12/09

    @Brad Brown: But if we have learned anything from Art Bell Coast to Coast, Sgt. Mark Todd is actually a Reptoid, and in order to stay below the radar, they will undo the Obama administrations tinkering, so nothing appears amiss and arouses suspicion. #kimberlydenisemunley
     Reply
    GitEmSteveDave_ForgotNametag was starred GitEmSteveDave_ForgotNametag was unstarred
    Image of Mediahohoho Mediahohoho
    11/12/09

    In reply to Who Really Shot the Fort Hood Shooter?
    But wait...wouldn't the current administration just naturally favor the African American man over the plucky Caucasian woman? #kimberlydenisemunley
     Reply
    Mediahohoho was starred Mediahohoho was unstarred
    Image of New Gonzo Drifter New Gonzo Drifter
    11/12/09

    @Mediahohoho: Also hilarious. #kimberlydenisemunley
     Reply
    New Gonzo Drifter was starred New Gonzo Drifter was unstarred
    Image of britneyspearstears britneyspearstears
    11/12/09

    @Mediahohoho: topical. #kimberlydenisemunley
     Reply
    britneyspearstears was starred britneyspearstears was unstarred
    Image of raincoaster raincoaster
    11/12/09

    In reply to Who Really Shot the Fort Hood Shooter?
    Was there a grassy knoll nearby? If so, Vanity Fair will be ALL OVER this story. #kimberlydenisemunley
     Reply
    raincoaster was starred raincoaster was unstarred
    Image of New Gonzo Drifter New Gonzo Drifter
    11/12/09

    @raincoaster: Hilarious. #kimberlydenisemunley
     Reply
    New Gonzo Drifter was starred New Gonzo Drifter was unstarred
    Earlier discussions Other discussions Show all discussions Show featured discussions only Start a new discussion

Login

Enter your username and password.

Please enter a username.
Please enter your password.
logging in
Login via Facebook | Sign Up | Forgot Password?

Reset Password

Please enter your email address to have your password reset.

Please enter your email address.
Please enter a valid email address.
requesting password reset

Register

Registering will give you a user profile and the ability to add other users as friends. To become a commenter, however, you need to audition.

Want to know more? Consult the Comment FAQ and legal terms.

Please enter a username.
Please enter a password.
Please confirm your password.
Passwords are not identical.
Please enter a valid email address.
registration sent, waiting for reply

Submit Your Comment

You don't need to login to comment. Just enter your email address below.

See how your address will be displayed in the Comment FAQ.

Please enter a valid email address.
Please enter a valid email address.
logging in

Login with your Facebook or Gawker account.

Sign up here.



  • Archives
  • About
  • Advertising
  • Legal
  • Help
  • Report a Bug
  • FAQ
Original material is licensed under a Creative Commons License permitting non-commercial sharing with attribution.