I wanted to like this, but...I'm starting to hate it as much as I hated Ghetto Pass. Why would a smart and clever as hell writer be so heavyhanded? The points are very valid, but the delivery not so much. Sorry. I want to see more T.A.N., but not this.
I agree that the points are valid. As for the rest of your assessment, you've observed qualities I've never seen in this writer in any piece he has ever contributed to Gawker.
I like the concept of what you're doing here T.A.N. and I want to see more of it. I had more to say about persona vs. writer, but I can't phrase it in a way that doesn't make me sound like a total ass. So, yeah. See you here next weekend.
@jasonelias: There's a reason I've hearted you! Using autotune (I can't distinguish between good and bad, frankly) would have recognized the current (and, lamentably, future) state of popular music, while highlighting its deficiencies.
@souldecirce: Heh heh, thank you! You know hearing Jay-Z with autotune would have been hilarious. I think all autotune is bad really. I can always hear it. Oddly enough it's in a lot of country music too.
Loving the old stuff--even superduper old stuff like Edison Cylinders and "White Christmas"--does not itself make one a curmudgeon. (It doesn't because that shit is golden and awesome, for serious.) Hell, liking the old stuff more than the new stuff doesn't necessarily make one a curmudgeon, either.
If Rosen was a real pop music curmudgeon, he wouldn't merely say that Raising Hell was the best hip-hop album ever--he'd say its besting was an impossbility, that everything after it (or after some point far into the past) wasn't even really hip-hop, and that this new and awful mutant interloper music with the same name wasn't even worth the slightest thought. And however goofy his analysis of "DOA" might be I don't think that's what happening here.
06/21/09
This seems like blather about nothing.
EVERYTHING is on the web if you look. Everything.
06/21/09
06/21/09
06/21/09
I agree that the points are valid. As for the rest of your assessment, you've observed qualities I've never seen in this writer in any piece he has ever contributed to Gawker.
06/20/09
06/20/09
06/20/09
06/20/09
06/20/09
06/20/09
06/20/09
06/20/09
06/20/09
06/15/09
06/14/09
06/14/09
jasonelias for music mogul!
06/14/09
06/14/09
ha. yeah, kind of like takeover with Nas where he used effects to make it funny and make his point. i third you on this suggestion.
06/14/09
06/14/09
If Rosen was a real pop music curmudgeon, he wouldn't merely say that Raising Hell was the best hip-hop album ever--he'd say its besting was an impossbility, that everything after it (or after some point far into the past) wasn't even really hip-hop, and that this new and awful mutant interloper music with the same name wasn't even worth the slightest thought. And however goofy his analysis of "DOA" might be I don't think that's what happening here.
06/14/09