• Profile logout login

#recessionomics#msg176001

Gawker

Share Cancel
   
Upload an image | Add an image URL
×

logging in
  • FAQ. Include # before tag:
  • #tips,
  • #stalker,
  • #opencaption,
  • #internalmemos,
  • etc.

New York, 8:47 AM
Mon Nov 30
21 posts in the last 24 hours

Team

Tip Your Editors:
tips@gawker.com
Tipline: 646-214-8138

Editor-in-Chief:
Gabriel Snyder | Email

West Coast Editor:
Richard Rushfield | Email

Contributing Editors:

Valleywag:
Ryan Tate | Email

Media:
Hamilton Nolan | Email

Politics:
Alex Pareene | Email

Investigations:
John Cook | Email

Entertainment:
Brian Moylan | Email

Nights:
Adrian Chen | Email
Azaria Jagger | Email
Ravi Somaiya | Email

Weekends:
Foster Kamer | Email

Video Editor:
Richard Blakeley | Email

SUBSCRIBE TO Gawker RSS

New: Breaking news and daily top stories via email
4260 Subscribers
Gawker
  • Your version of Internet Explorer is not supported. Please upgrade to the most recent version in order to view comments.

    Dsmvwl  Admin  Promote to frontpage Approve user Ban user ×
    Image of krismry krismry
    01:30 AM

    In reply to The Disconcerting Reality of Food Stamp America
    The original purpose behind establishing a food stamp program, not incidentally administered by the USDA, was to provide another indirect agricultural subsidy.
    The details historically came under various provisions of the Farm Bill of the moment. Not so much to do with welfare.
     Reply
    Edited by krismry at 11/30/09 1:31 AM krismry was starred krismry was unstarred
    Image of howdybeep (runs with monkey wrenches) howdybeep (runs with monkey wrenches)
    01:01 AM

    In reply to The Disconcerting Reality of Food Stamp America
    When I was twenty and working full-time as a copyrunner/perpetual intern to pay for tuition and rent, I found out I could qualify for food stamps.

    So I went down to the office and applied. The look on the woman's face was bad enough, until she said, "Honey, you're white. White girls in college don't go on food stamps. You call your daddy and just have him take you to Albertson's once a week. You'll be fine."

    And then she turned back to her coworker to gossip.

    I left, ashamed. Didn't even try arguing with her. I ended up surviving on a two-pronged method: prodding my mom to take me to Costco, where I would buy bulk-sized boxes of Bisquick, which would keep me fed through the week, until I'd go out on a date over the weekend and chow down on the dude's dime. It was the only way I survived until I moved in with my boyfriend-now-husband.

    Which is what I think about during my monthly donation trips to the pantry. Nobody should have to be that hungry and that desperate.
     Reply
    howdybeep (runs with monkey wrenches) was starred howdybeep (runs with monkey wrenches) was unstarred
    Image of Cicada Cicada
    11/29/09

    In reply to The Disconcerting Reality of Food Stamp America
    I think the blame and shame bullshit is a thing that people do to reassure themselves that they'll never be poor enough to need food stamps. If you believe everyone on food stamps is just lazy and unmotivated, then you have complete control over whether or not you become poor.
    It isn't logical and it doesn't reflect the reality of poverty in this country, but I'm sure it makes people feel better on some level. Too bad it also means they feel like they can turn their backs on their fellow human beings (while feeling superior, no less).
     Reply
    Cicada was starred Cicada was unstarred
    Image of Atilla the Bun Atilla the Bun
    05:02 AM

    @Cicada: Excellent point, and I agree. The reality that there are people this genuinely destitute in the good 'ole U.S. of A is not something most people want to think about. They certainly don't want to think "there by the grace of god go I." So they instead mock and blame.

    And the idea that it's some kind of family planning issue...even assuming that is true, the idea that some child should have to starve or otherwise suffer because of his/her parent's own stupidity is ridiculous. No doubt many of the people chiding the parents in that situation are also staunchly pro-life.
     Reply
    Atilla the Bun was starred Atilla the Bun was unstarred
    Image of D2theMatthews D2theMatthews
    11/29/09

    In reply to The Disconcerting Reality of Food Stamp America
    There's something really reassuring to read through these comments and see that the same people that gab about Lady Gaga's alleged penis can discuss social ills in an even more intelligent and engrossing manner. This is why I like this place.
     Reply
    D2theMatthews was starred D2theMatthews was unstarred
    Image of Foster Kamer Foster Kamer
    12:00 AM

    @D2theMatthews: Here here.
     Reply
    Foster Kamer was starred Foster Kamer was unstarred
    Image of booge booge
    11/29/09

    In reply to The Disconcerting Reality of Food Stamp America
    In California, we have another sucker-punch: mandatory furloughs for some State workers! You think you were poor, now you have three days a month with no pay to think about how much poorer you are now. Imagine how much that fucks up single parents of multiple kids who were just eking by. What if you have a parent in a nursing home? Oh, I forgot: that's their fault. Even if they were making all their bills before the furloughs.

    Watch it happen: the next popular game/reality show will be around debt. You'll have to humiliate yourself on camera, let everyone know what your credit history is, outwit and outlast all the other debtors in a newfangled, televised debtors' prison. The winner will have all his/her bills paid off and have his/her credit score raised to 700!
     Reply
    themediatrix promoted this comment booge was starred booge was unstarred
    Image of Baroness Baroness
    11/29/09

    In reply to The Disconcerting Reality of Food Stamp America
    I'll tell you what killed me about reading this saddening article this morning on paper.

    That's the shame the people who spoke to the reporter felt. Some of these parents were only desperate to feed their kids. While both parents were working. And they felt ashamed at this assistance.

    The fact is : the working class has been utterly destroyed, decimated, brought to its knees by thirty years of Reaganism, Republican ideology in the US. And the culture makes the victims feel shame for it. As if it's their own fault.

    The tens of millions of working-class people who've lost their jobs due to outsourcing, factory closings, pay cuts, concessions and disappearing blue-collar work are told it's their own fault. If only you went to the right school, did the right thing, pulled yourself up by your bootstraps. Tens of millions of workers all thinking it's their own personal failure that they lost their good job when the factory closed.

    This is unbelievably cruel. In America, everyone thinks they're middle class. It's impolite to speak of it. But I am appalled and disgusted that our national media scarcely sees fit to look closely at the destruction- the working class, the backbone of American prosperity and industriousness, has been wiped out. Is starved. Is left to blame themselves that they aren't CEO's or highly paid television commentators.

    Instead, let's criticize how Obama gave his polite bow to the Emperor of Japan, whether he should have , and next up we'll have a right wing retard make the reasonable case that Obama should have punched the guy out in revengefor Pearl Harbor, by some inordinately respected right-wing warmonger.

    In the meantime, the Republican party's long war on the good people of America continues. We have no money for health care but we'll spend ten times that on foreign wars. Sign your son up! We've eradicated your jobs and lives, it's cheaper to enslave overseas. But stop your whining. Not our fault you didn't go to Harvard. Your kids are hungry? Here's your foodstamps, loser. Til we get rid of that too.
     Reply
    Edited by Baroness at 11/29/09 9:25 PM Baroness was starred Baroness was unstarred
    Image of BookishLookish BookishLookish
    11/29/09

    @Baroness: Thank you, 'Ness.
     Reply
    BookishLookish was starred BookishLookish was unstarred
    Image of saralovesyou saralovesyou
    11/29/09

    @Baroness: I could never say this better.

    Call what I ask next some form of stupid optimism: how do we de-Reaganize the country?
     Reply
    saralovesyou was starred saralovesyou was unstarred
    Image of Baroness Baroness
    11/29/09

    @BookishLookish: One does go on when the wine is flowing, Miss Lookish. And Foster's a tolerant host, the weekends are for Op-Eds I'd never dare during the week. Much love to you, dashing lady. Elsewhere tonight you introduced "tug shop" into my tiny brain, and I must go hit my diary with that, as well as the bedtime injections that I'm not sure are necessary, but are court-ordered.
     Reply
    Baroness was starred Baroness was unstarred
    Image of BookishLookish BookishLookish
    11/29/09

    @Baroness: Darling, I stole "tug shop" from our beloved Son of Spam. Enjoy your mariani wine, clink clink!
     Reply
    BookishLookish was starred BookishLookish was unstarred
    Image of stacey.f.jaffe stacey.f.jaffe
    11/29/09

    @saralovesyou: as small as it may seem (check out bookish, below) volunteer. even if it's 4 hours every three months.

    if it's policy you're interested in - (again, as small as it may seem) send your congressmen a letter/call them/fax them. even once. (six times works too, btw) :D

    optimism is never stupid. non-action when you feel an emotional reaction to a problem is, perhaps, defeatism.
     Reply
    Wrapitup promoted this comment stacey.f.jaffe was starred stacey.f.jaffe was unstarred
    Image of ScottRaphael ScottRaphael
    11/29/09

    @Baroness: The country is in a blind madness. The people at the very top, who have pretty much all the money, could easily help heal things by taking the marginal profit cuts that would come from bringing outsourced jobs back to America - they wouldn't even need to raise prices at all, just stop passing the rolled up bundles of money between each other like a basketball, and start spreading it around to their loyal employees. Somehow this idea gets portrayed as anti-American, but I don't know how. I think being rewarded for being a hard, loyal worker is the ultimate expression of the American ideal and this Regan-esque idea of the guys at the top profiting off the work of their employees, giving them but the bare minimum in return is the opposite of that ideal.

    The trickle-down economy is the biggest scam in American history. It's completely nuts that people even bought into it. Considering that wealthy people tend to SAVE far more money, percentage wise, than they spend compared to the middle and lower class (who need to spend that larger percentage of money on food and shelter), it makes no sense just from a numerical standpoint. But even further, it's not like these wealthy people are waltzing into a mom and pop shop to buy their stuff - they buy their consumer goods from huge chains just like everyone else, putting their money into the pockets of other wealthy people, with only 7-10 dollars an hour "trickling down" to the average worker. Then, all these people with their infinite wealth get policy power by either befriending politicians (lobbying) or becoming politicians (Bloomberg, Bush, et al billionaire politicians). Also, the wonders of globalization have made loyalty of American company's to American interests pretty much non-existent, so no company or executive will stick their necks out to help everyone if it even marginally affects their own bottom line, and instead uses tax-deductible charity donations to make it seem like they're helping the people, when they're just cutting back their government expenses. Oh, and let's not forget the wonders of high-priced accounting practices, which cut down the taxes paid by the wealthy and huge corporations back to a tiny percent, whereas the average joe has no access to this and has to pay a monstrous chunk of his income each year.

    Shit, that's pretty much a manifesto I just wrote - long and unfocused. I'll probably have the FBI at my house in ten minutes.
     Reply
    Baroness promoted this comment Edited by ScottRaphael at 11/29/09 10:03 PM ScottRaphael was starred ScottRaphael was unstarred
    Image of Lysergic Asset Lysergic Asset
    11/29/09

    @ScottRaphael: I'll probably have the FBI at my house in ten minutes. You mean they weren't behind you as you were typing?

    All jesting aside, and with sincere apologies to Dylan Thomas, I think it's essential that you continue to "rage, rage against the lying of the right."

    I'd like to believe, as Dr. King did, that the arc of history will eventually bend towards justice.
     Reply
    Lysergic Asset was starred Lysergic Asset was unstarred
    Image of Foster Kamer Foster Kamer
    11/29/09

    @Baroness: That was truly wonderful. Great work.
     Reply
    Foster Kamer was starred Foster Kamer was unstarred
    Image of Baroness Baroness
    11/29/09

    @BookishLookish: Clink! m'love. And thank you, Foster.
     Reply
    Edited by Baroness at 11/29/09 10:55 PM Baroness was starred Baroness was unstarred
    Image of ScottRaphael ScottRaphael
    11/29/09

    @Lysergic Asset: The rage of the unemployed college graduate above the poverty line is as impotent as Bob Dole without his ED meds, but just for you, I'll keep it up <3
     Reply
    ScottRaphael was starred ScottRaphael was unstarred
    Image of Eh-ron Eh-ron
    11/29/09

    @Baroness: Simply beautiful. Unfortunately, everyword of it is true.
     Reply
    Baroness promoted this comment Eh-ron was starred Eh-ron was unstarred
    Image of mommy_dearest mommy_dearest
    11/29/09

    @Baroness: It is exactly this. There is no shortage of shame in the food lines. We don't need to shame them more.
     Reply
    mommy_dearest was starred mommy_dearest was unstarred
    Image of Lysergic Asset Lysergic Asset
    12:18 AM

    @ScottRaphael: "Men can starve from a lack of self-realization as much as they can from a lack of bread." - Richard Wright

    That's definitely not something you need to work on.

    Keep shining!
     Reply
    Lysergic Asset was starred Lysergic Asset was unstarred
    Image of DahlELama DahlELama
    12:22 AM

    @Baroness: Every time you speak, I wish I could heart you again.
     Reply
    DahlELama was starred DahlELama was unstarred
    Image of atlasfugged atlasfugged
    12:34 AM

    @Baroness: +10^100. God, you are a gem.
     Reply
    Baroness promoted this comment Edited by atlasfugged at 11/30/09 12:34 AM atlasfugged was starred atlasfugged was unstarred
    Image of If_I_Had_a_Poodle If_I_Had_a_Poodle
    11/29/09

    In reply to The Disconcerting Reality of Food Stamp America
    Eisenhower was probably the last Repbulican with a heart or a pulse

    [www.informationclearinghouse.info]

    Cross of Iron Speech

    Address by President Dwight D. Eisenhower "The Chance for Peace" delivered before the American Society of Newspaper Editors, April 16,1953.

    Every gun that is made, every warship launched, every rocket fired signifies, in the final sense, a theft from those who hunger and are not fed, those who are cold and are not clothed.

    This world in arms in not spending money alone.

    It is spending the sweat of its laborers, the genius of its scientists, the hopes of its children.

    The cost of one modern heavy bomber is this: a modern brick school in more than 30 cities.

    It is two electric power plants, each serving a town of 60,000 population.

    It is two fine, fully equipped hospitals.

    It is some 50 miles of concrete highway.

    We pay for a single fighter with a half million bushels of wheat.

    We pay for a single destroyer with new homes that could have housed more than 8,000 people.

    This, I repeat, is the best way of life to be found on the road the world has been taking.

    This is not a way of life at all, in any true sense. Under the cloud of threatening war, it is humanity hanging from a cross of iron.

    ...

    If we strive but fail and the world remains armed against itself, it at least need be divided no longer in its clear knowledge of who has condemned humankind to this fate
     Reply
    If_I_Had_a_Poodle was starred If_I_Had_a_Poodle was unstarred
    Image of Lysergic Asset Lysergic Asset
    11/29/09

    @If_I_Had_a_Poodle: Reading that gave me chills. Thank you so much for posting this on this thread.

    I imagine Eisenhower would be hanging out with Dennis Kucinich on the 'believes in fairies, tree gnomes, social justice and world peace' modern political scale.

    Didn't his granddaughter work for Obama's campaign?
     Reply
    Lysergic Asset was starred Lysergic Asset was unstarred
    Image of If_I_Had_a_Poodle If_I_Had_a_Poodle
    11/29/09

    @Lysergic Asset: Didn't know about his grand-daughter.

    Ike would be tried for treason by Beck, Limbaugh and Palin -- the idiot three musketeers that are leading the red state, hate blinded, low IQ masses down the garden path. The smarter richer people who support that agenda are at least working in their own short term interests. The misled masses are just ignorant and hateful. Of course it won't be good for the riches when things here become like in Latin America, where it's all walled compounds and armed bodyguards because the poors have been so completely dispossessed of everything that they really don't give a shit anymore.
     Reply
    If_I_Had_a_Poodle was starred If_I_Had_a_Poodle was unstarred
    Image of Lysergic Asset Lysergic Asset
    11/29/09

    @If_I_Had_a_Poodle: I live in Mexico. Yo entiendo perfectamente.

    Julie Nixon Eisenhower actually married Ike's son and supported Obama:

    [thecaucus.blogs.nytimes.com]
     Reply
    Lysergic Asset was starred Lysergic Asset was unstarred
    Image of If_I_Had_a_Poodle If_I_Had_a_Poodle
    11/29/09

    @Lysergic Asset: Rock on, rock on
     Reply
    If_I_Had_a_Poodle was starred If_I_Had_a_Poodle was unstarred
    Image of BookishLookish BookishLookish
    11/29/09

    In reply to The Disconcerting Reality of Food Stamp America
    My synagogue contributes to two local shelters and we donate time and resources to a food bank, where I also volunteer. The shame and outright agony in the eyes of people coming in for food for their children will break your heart in two. We always have a play area for the little ones, so they are distracted from the pain in their parents' faces. Open your eyes, neocons. In the richest nation in the world, more children are still going hungry. "Food stamps is [sic] quasi money"? Fuck you, shitbag, why don't you live on crackers and water for a few days and see how you like it.
     Reply
    BookishLookish was starred BookishLookish was unstarred
    Image of If_I_Had_a_Poodle If_I_Had_a_Poodle
    11/29/09

    @BookishLookish: What are you, a liberal commie Jew, giving a shit about people who have less than you? <3 <3 <3
     Reply
    If_I_Had_a_Poodle was starred If_I_Had_a_Poodle was unstarred
    Image of Lysergic Asset Lysergic Asset
    11/29/09

    @BookishLookish: Okay, so now I'm crying. Again, what is wrong with this world?
     Reply
    Lysergic Asset was starred Lysergic Asset was unstarred
    Image of BookishLookish BookishLookish
    11/29/09

    @If_I_Had_a_Poodle: I'm actually a registered Democrat, but thank you, my grandmother was a Communist. Comes the revolution, I am hoping my pretty well-dressed head will be spared.
     Reply
    BookishLookish was starred BookishLookish was unstarred
    Image of If_I_Had_a_Poodle If_I_Had_a_Poodle
    11/29/09

    @BookishLookish: Amen and pass the borscht.
     Reply
    If_I_Had_a_Poodle was starred If_I_Had_a_Poodle was unstarred
    Image of ScottRaphael ScottRaphael
    11/29/09

    In reply to The Disconcerting Reality of Food Stamp America
    The right's positions on just about everything are endlessly counter-intuitive. We can't teach kids about safe sex in school because we need to shame them into abstinence. If and when they do get pregnant because they weren't ashamed of sex enough and weren't educated properly (they'll say "because they were stupid"), they shouldn't be allowed to get abortions, and if they do they should be shamed by protests and fear clinic bombings. So, now that they can't get these abortions, none of these people should be able to get food stamps or welfare to help them out when they find they can't afford to pay for food for their accidental children. Then when they can't pay their debts they should lose their homes and never be able to get loans again, and we should jack their current interest rates through the roof. If they get involved in drugs after the succumb to the crippling shame and depression of all this, they should be shamed and jailed even more with no regard to drug education or recovery help.

    This fucking country.
     Reply
    Wrapitup approved this comment ScottRaphael was starred ScottRaphael was unstarred
    Image of Wrapitup Wrapitup
    11/29/09

    @ScottRaphael: While I totally disagree with the sentiment of your very last sentence, I think you summed up the right's shame-based approach to influencing behavior really well.
     Reply
    Wrapitup was starred Wrapitup was unstarred
    Image of Lysergic Asset Lysergic Asset
    11/29/09

    @ScottRaphael: I think it may be more like "this fucking world." Take a look at Maslow's hierarchy of needs and you'll see that by keeping people tethered to the base of the triangle (struggling for subsistence), those in power - read: the wealthy - distract them from any higher aims, which obviously include banding together to rectify the profound, egregious and never-ending injustices which propel the human condition.
     Reply
    Lysergic Asset was starred Lysergic Asset was unstarred
    Image of ScottRaphael ScottRaphael
    11/29/09

    @Wrapitup: The bitter aftertaste of the ooze (oo's) is still lingering in my mouth. I do still love America, it's just hard to not get a little jaded.
     Reply
    Edited by ScottRaphael at 11/29/09 9:40 PM ScottRaphael was starred ScottRaphael was unstarred
    Image of Wrapitup Wrapitup
    11/29/09

    @ScottRaphael: Far be it from me to accuse someone of not being patriotic enough. Jade away, bro. I just have a somewhat different POV is all.
     Reply
    Wrapitup was starred Wrapitup was unstarred
    Image of ScottRaphael ScottRaphael
    11/29/09

    @Wrapitup: Why do you hate freedom?
     Reply
    ScottRaphael was starred ScottRaphael was unstarred
    Image of Wrapitup Wrapitup
    11/29/09

    @ScottRaphael: And that too when we're fighting a war on turr.
     Reply
    Wrapitup was starred Wrapitup was unstarred
    Image of TroisFilles TroisFilles
    11/29/09

    In reply to The Disconcerting Reality of Food Stamp America
    You have no idea what it's like until you've been a name on a paper mitten. Humbling doesn't begin to cover it. I wish all these recipients a better 2010.
     Reply
    Wrapitup promoted this comment TroisFilles was starred TroisFilles was unstarred
    Image of atlasspanked atlasspanked
    11/29/09

    In reply to The Disconcerting Reality of Food Stamp America
    "..the majority of food stamp recipients reside in red states."

    Uh, make that the Old Dixie. I live in Utah and, along with Nevada and Idaho, we yield to NO ONE in our redness, but are among the lowest food stamp recipients.

    Fortunately, we have lots of roadkill.
     Reply
    Foster Kamer promoted this comment atlasspanked was starred atlasspanked was unstarred
    Image of Foster Kamer Foster Kamer
    11/29/09

    @atlasspanked: Yeah, but Vegas is up, what was it 80%? It's ugly here.
     Reply
    Foster Kamer was starred Foster Kamer was unstarred
    Image of If_I_Had_a_Poodle If_I_Had_a_Poodle
    11/29/09

    In reply to The Disconcerting Reality of Food Stamp America
    This is one tiny step toward the white people in the square states who think social welfare programs are for The Other gaining some humility and first hand experience and compassion by experiencing it first hand for themselves, when forces beyond one's control make daily life all but impossible without a social safety net

    Amen
     Reply
    If_I_Had_a_Poodle was starred If_I_Had_a_Poodle was unstarred
    Image of Lysergic Asset Lysergic Asset
    11/29/09

    @If_I_Had_a_Poodle: I shudder to think how many of them are watching Fox News and blaming Obama for their plight.
     Reply
    Lysergic Asset was starred Lysergic Asset was unstarred
    Image of If_I_Had_a_Poodle If_I_Had_a_Poodle
    11/29/09

    @Lysergic Asset: Most of them.
     Reply
    If_I_Had_a_Poodle was starred If_I_Had_a_Poodle was unstarred
    Image of Unsolicited Advice Unsolicited Advice
    11/29/09

    In reply to The Disconcerting Reality of Food Stamp America
    Well.

    There are two types of people in the world. Type 1 thinks that there is enough to go around. Type 2 doesn't.

    That tends to drive sharing decisions. Call me a type 2. Life is a limited resources problem. Unless you've discovered a source of unlimited energy?
     Reply
    Unsolicited Advice was starred Unsolicited Advice was unstarred
    Image of If_I_Had_a_Poodle If_I_Had_a_Poodle
    11/29/09

    @Unsolicited Advice: What? There's not enough to go around? In the richest country on earth, where we spend the annual cost of the entire social safety net, riddled with holes as it is, on a single month of killing people and blowing shit up in Iraq? What?
     Reply
    If_I_Had_a_Poodle was starred If_I_Had_a_Poodle was unstarred
    Image of BookishLookish BookishLookish
    11/29/09

    @Unsolicited Advice: You're an unlimited asshole and I'd like to see you go hungry for a week.
     Reply
    BookishLookish was starred BookishLookish was unstarred
    Image of Niko Bellic Niko Bellic
    11/29/09

    @Unsolicited Advice: Call me a type 2.

    I am going to call you an idiot.
     Reply
    Niko Bellic was starred Niko Bellic was unstarred
    Image of Wrapitup Wrapitup
    11/29/09

    @Unsolicited Advice: What are you saying exactly? Are you saying the poor should just shut up and suck it up?
     Reply
    Wrapitup was starred Wrapitup was unstarred
    Image of Unsolicited Advice Unsolicited Advice
    11/29/09

    @BookishLookish:

    I would, to feed my family. Just never yours.
     Reply
    Unsolicited Advice was starred Unsolicited Advice was unstarred
    Image of Lysergic Asset Lysergic Asset
    11/29/09

    @Niko Bellic: You are so wonderful.
     Reply
    Lysergic Asset was starred Lysergic Asset was unstarred
    Image of BookishLookish BookishLookish
    11/29/09

    @Unsolicited Advice: Excuse me, but who raised you with so little love that you don't understand that it is unacceptable for ANYONE to go hungry, ever?
     Reply
    BookishLookish was starred BookishLookish was unstarred
    Image of Unsolicited Advice Unsolicited Advice
    11/29/09

    @BookishLookish:

    What part of "limited resources" don't you understand? Like I said, until you have an infinite energy source, you're stuck finding ways to share. Some of the most efficient ways involve some unfortunate people from bad situations and locations starving to death. Sorry.
     Reply
    Unsolicited Advice was starred Unsolicited Advice was unstarred
    Image of BookishLookish BookishLookish
    11/29/09

    @Lysergic Asset: I'll second that. Niko for World Dictator for Life.
     Reply
    BookishLookish was starred BookishLookish was unstarred
    Image of BookishLookish BookishLookish
    11/29/09

    @Unsolicited Advice: Fucking unacceptable, Unsolicited Advice. I hope you have some shitty pencil-pushing job guaranteed you for life if you do not make a fuss about anything and have no control over the welfare of another human being. Your concepts of "efficiency"? Shove 'em where the monkey shoves the nuts. I've seen the babies crying, sweetheart. Why don't you try?
     Reply
    BookishLookish was starred BookishLookish was unstarred
    Image of Unsolicited Advice Unsolicited Advice
    11/29/09

    @BookishLookish:

    I'm not sure your emotional response to suffering is going to make the rice yields go up, Bookish. I can't engage you in an argument about how you feel about poverty, it's purposeless. All you're going to do is rail at me for being the messenger of the world's unfair realities, and that doesn't seem like it accomplishes anything.
     Reply
    Unsolicited Advice was starred Unsolicited Advice was unstarred
    Image of kung fu lola kung fu lola
    11/29/09

    @Unsolicited Advice: Who decides what is "bad"?
     Reply
    Unsolicited Advice promoted this comment kung fu lola was starred kung fu lola was unstarred
    Image of Unsolicited Advice Unsolicited Advice
    11/29/09

    @kung fu lola:

    Well, I'd say that Somalia is an objectively bad place to be born. If it interests you enough we can probably develop an algorithm from per-capita GDP, poverty rates, disease, war, rape, etc. statistics.
     Reply
    Unsolicited Advice was starred Unsolicited Advice was unstarred
    Image of BookishLookish BookishLookish
    11/29/09

    @Unsolicited Advice: Again, I must tell you, this is unacceptable. And please don't pull the emotional card on me. I have a right to be angry, and so do you, *if you allow yourself to be,* that is. Your view of the inevitability of poverty is morally disgraceful. There IS enough, in this country, if we only try. You prefer the easy way out of abstract economic theory, do you? Good luck with that.
     Reply
    BookishLookish was starred BookishLookish was unstarred
    Image of Unsolicited Advice Unsolicited Advice
    11/29/09

    @BookishLookish:

    I'm not sure your anger solves more than my mathematics. In fact, I'm positive that 5 minutes of patient analysis can accomplish more than all the undirected anger in the world. There is nothing abstract about starvation, but the solutions to it are. And currently, solutions that exclude starvation don't exist - not unless you have an infinite amount of arable land and potable water or the political will to fix all of Earth at a specific population.
     Reply
    Unsolicited Advice was starred Unsolicited Advice was unstarred
    Image of kung fu lola kung fu lola
    11/29/09

    @Unsolicited Advice: So, your definition of "bad" is based on the choices of warlords and others who seized control undemocratically. Those who starve, according to your wishes, would do so for no reason within their control. Hm. Good to know.
     Reply
    kung fu lola was starred kung fu lola was unstarred
    Image of BookishLookish BookishLookish
    11/29/09

    @Unsolicited Advice: My anger is completely directed. And I am not talking about the whole world, but your brothers and sisters in this country, where we have the means to prevent people from going hungry. But you're having a cute, show-offy conversation with yourself, so go on, tell us everything you know about mathematics, infinite arable land, etc.
     Reply
    BookishLookish was starred BookishLookish was unstarred
    Image of Wrapitup Wrapitup
    11/29/09

    @Unsolicited Advice: And if those "some unfortunate people from bad situations and locations" who're "starving to death" are your children? Then what? Will you stand back and find the most efficient way for them to die quickly?
     Reply
    Wrapitup was starred Wrapitup was unstarred
    Image of Lysergic Asset Lysergic Asset
    11/29/09

    @Unsolicited Advice:
     Reply
    Lysergic Asset was starred Lysergic Asset was unstarred
    Image of Unsolicited Advice Unsolicited Advice
    11/29/09

    @Wrapitup:

    Of course not. And a few thousand fathers fail to succeed in their wild quest to find sustenance every day. If you think starvation is some sort of "orderly affair" you're wrong. I didn't ask a single person to simply accept fate on an individual level. I spoke in the aggregate.
     Reply
    Unsolicited Advice was starred Unsolicited Advice was unstarred
    Image of Unsolicited Advice Unsolicited Advice
    11/29/09

    @BookishLookish:

    Who am I showing off for, Bookish? What am I showing off? I don't understand your point of view.
     Reply
    Unsolicited Advice was starred Unsolicited Advice was unstarred
    Image of Lysergic Asset Lysergic Asset
    11/29/09

    @kung fu lola: It's an unwinnable argument. I just sent him this pic and left it at that.
     Reply
    Lysergic Asset was starred Lysergic Asset was unstarred
    Image of Unsolicited Advice Unsolicited Advice
    11/29/09

    @kung fu lola:

    Correct. I'm not stating that they're responsible for starving through some moral flaw. They were simply born in the wrong location.
     Reply
    Unsolicited Advice was starred Unsolicited Advice was unstarred
    Image of Wrapitup Wrapitup
    11/29/09

    @Unsolicited Advice: The aggregate is composed of individuals. You're basically saying that it's too bad that people have to starve but that's just what happens when there isn't enough for everyone. Have you ever starved? Have you ever struggled to make it through the day on meager rations?
     Reply
    Wrapitup was starred Wrapitup was unstarred
    Image of Unsolicited Advice Unsolicited Advice
    11/29/09

    @Wrapitup:

    I'm not sure you'd believe my answer if I said yes, and I'm positive the answer is irrelevant.
     Reply
    Unsolicited Advice was starred Unsolicited Advice was unstarred
    Image of allyzay allyzay
    11/29/09

    @BookishLookish: He knows next to nothing about those things (math, "infinite arable land", etc). Everyone's TRIED. I decided a while ago he's just some asshole trying to rile people up for laughs because he doesn't actually explain his opinions other than say that he knows everything about math/the economy/rabbits/whatever you wanna put here. It's an admirable quest you're on here but I think at this point this "person" should just be ignored. When you're arguing a specific welfare system and its merits and dismerits in the United States and someone starts shouting about how people in Somalia are destined to starve and then refuses to actually answer the subject at hand...it's not worth it.
     Reply
    allyzay was starred allyzay was unstarred
    Image of Wrapitup Wrapitup
    11/29/09

    @Unsolicited Advice: No, I believe you. And the answer is absolutely relevant. I don't think you're anywhere near as blase about poverty as you come off. I think you're very angry about it and you feel very helpless about it and this nonchalance is the best response that you've come up with. Just a theory, like yours.
     Reply
    Wrapitup was starred Wrapitup was unstarred
    Image of larala larala
    11/29/09

    @Unsolicited Advice: Hunger is more of a distribution problem than a supply problem, particularly in this country. Days before this article ran, a study came out showing that as much as 40% of food goes to waste in the U.S. It's much more complicated than "rice yields."
     Reply
    Wrapitup promoted this comment larala was starred larala was unstarred
    Image of allyzay allyzay
    11/29/09

    @Unsolicited Advice: I can only extrapolate from here, since otherwise your commentary about the wealth of the United States, which is what we're talking about, is wholly off-topic coldness towards countries in Africa, that you believe that people born in the portions of the U.S. where welfare usage is up also were simply born in the wrong location? If you'd like to argue that point, please keep going. Otherwise tits or GTFO.
     Reply
    allyzay was starred allyzay was unstarred
    Image of Unsolicited Advice Unsolicited Advice
    11/29/09

    @allyzay:

    Considering that Detroit is a rough approximation of the countries in Africa I'm referring to, the argument seems portable. I know, Michigan humor.

    And yes, I believe that luck (or a lack thereof) has a terribly large impact on the ability of the hungry to receive adequate food. Remember that episode of The Wire where the crackhead mom sold the Rice-A-Roni?
     Reply
    Unsolicited Advice was starred Unsolicited Advice was unstarred
    Image of Unsolicited Advice Unsolicited Advice
    11/29/09

    @allyzay:

    You don't know a thing about my qualifications. What's with your need to discuss me? This isn't the first time.

    There are a thousand inputs in this discussion, macro and micro. We're talking weather patterns, global warming, whether or not a guy in a market sees a kid stealing, the outcome of a meeting between two warlords huddling over a create of supplies.

    Foodstamps are a microcosm of the global mission to determine how we feed the hungry. It's such a general topic! Honestly, ignore me if you want, but my point - which I was general about, because this isn't exactly the forum for a data-driven discussion - is that the commodity everyone chases (food) is limited. It's an unassailable point.
     Reply
    Unsolicited Advice was starred Unsolicited Advice was unstarred
    Image of Niko Bellic Niko Bellic
    11/29/09

    @Unsolicited Advice: It's an unassailable point.

    It is. You are still an idiot.
     Reply
    Niko Bellic was starred Niko Bellic was unstarred
    Image of ParahSalin ParahSalin
    12:09 AM

    @Niko Bellic: Not only is he an idiot, he's also a starred idiot. That bothers me for some reason. Probably because I don't have one.
     Reply
    Niko Bellic promoted this comment ParahSalin was starred ParahSalin was unstarred
    Image of ParahSalin ParahSalin
    12:11 AM

    @Unsolicited Advice: "is that the commodity everyone chases (food) is limited. It's an unassailable point."

    We have so much food production in this country we put Mexican farmers out of business because we could grow it cheaper and ship it to their country than they could grow it. Food exports are our biggest export, so food obviously isn't the problem.
     Reply
    Niko Bellic promoted this comment ParahSalin was starred ParahSalin was unstarred
    Image of Niko Bellic Niko Bellic
    12:23 AM

    @ParahSalin: I don't have any kind of data to argue if there is (or if there could be) enough food for everyone in the world (or in this country). I do have enough data however on what this discussion is about: it's about a cold-ass pseudo-logical reaction as a defense mechanism among "the haves" when they are presented with the suffering of "the have nots". And here comes this idiot trotting right into it with his "unassailable point".
     Reply
    Edited by Niko Bellic at 11/30/09 12:30 AM Niko Bellic was starred Niko Bellic was unstarred
    Image of Unsolicited Advice Unsolicited Advice
    12:48 AM

    @ParahSalin:

    What do we pour on those crops to grow them? Food production is the end result of a complex integration of primarily imported products. EG: petroleum-based fertilizer. We are, of course, tremendous importers of oil - the world's largest, by far. American agribusiness is fueled by the interconnectivity of the global trade marketplace. You can't simplify it to "We have X food, let's hand it out."
     Reply
    Unsolicited Advice was starred Unsolicited Advice was unstarred
    Image of Unsolicited Advice Unsolicited Advice
    12:53 AM

    @Niko Bellic:

    You want to simplify the world, reduce it to suffering and amelioration. I get that. It cuts through the complexity of the world we actually live in. Your position is easy - people suffer and those that sit "idly" by while it takes place are complicit. You can rain condemnation and insults from your unsophisticated little foxhole like it matters. I hope it brings you the solace you're looking for.
     Reply
    Unsolicited Advice was starred Unsolicited Advice was unstarred
    Image of ParahSalin ParahSalin
    01:03 AM

    @Niko Bellic: Sorry, but this requires me to make a lame joke in the "assume = ass out of u and me" vein. Here goes: you know what they say about "unassailable," it makes an ass out of i and labels. There is defineitely plenty of food in this country, that's why we're all being fed so much, and why we export so much. We grow so much corn we've started making fuel out of it for no apparent reason. If you haven't seen the movie Food Inc. I would highly recommend it. Deregulation of the food industry has worked out almost as well as deregulation of the banking industry, with the added kicker that people get to DIE.
     Reply
    ParahSalin was starred ParahSalin was unstarred
    Image of Niko Bellic Niko Bellic
    01:20 AM

    @Unsolicited Advice: insults from your unsophisticated little foxhole

    Aaah, you really shouldn't have gone that far. "your New York apartment" would've been been enough!

    By the way, I am not (merely) insulting you, or (God forbid!) condemning you. I am ridiculing you. Which is basically all we ever do, here in my unsophisticated little foxhole.
     Reply
    Niko Bellic was starred Niko Bellic was unstarred
    Image of Atilla the Bun Atilla the Bun
    05:13 AM

    @larala: Thank you for pointing that out. There is simply no reason for most of the people in the world, and certainly in the United States, to go hungry from the perspective of "limited resources," so the whole argument on such grounds is a straw man.

    There is more than enough food available in the United States to feed the people within our borders. It's a matter of overcoming the various barriers to getting it to them, among them these dipshit ideas that it's some kind of survival of the fittest race to deserve it.
     Reply
    Edited by Atilla the Bun at 11/30/09 5:14 AM Atilla the Bun was starred Atilla the Bun was unstarred
    Image of skahammer skahammer
    08:06 AM

    @Unsolicited Advice: I sympathize with your point on finding analytical solutions to problems of scarcity, but I'm puzzled at how an apparent reliance on analytical thinking can possibly fail to lead one to @larala's point:

    Hunger is more of a distribution problem than a supply problem, particularly in this country.

    That's exactly right. In the U.S., anyway, supplies are at such a level that hunger is primarily a problem of political economy, not macro- or microeconomics. For such problems, purely analytical solutions are frequently helpful, but they're rarely sufficient by themselves -- since enduring solutions require us (the problem-solvers) to place values on certain nonquantifiable assets like rights to personal dignity or autonomous decisions on reproduction, etc.

    I've respected the points you've made before, but your mistaking problems of political economy for problems of pure macroeconomics seems like a serious analytical oversight. In fact I'd go so far as to say that it's inconsistent with a truly analytical approach to problem-solving.

    It's true, many public problems involve optimizing the use of scarce, discrete resources. But certain very complex problems implicate other, harder-to-quantify resources as well. The effort to address those problems analytically is still worth it -- but it's not sufficient, and in fact relying solely on quantitative analysis to address these problems can lead one to some quite regrettable conclusions. I suspect you realize this as well as anyone, actually.
     Reply
    Edited by skahammer at 11/30/09 8:09 AM skahammer was starred skahammer was unstarred
    Image of oudemia oudemia
    11/29/09

    In reply to The Disconcerting Reality of Food Stamp America
    If you think John J. Miller's thoughts are foetid (they are), take a gander about the readers who write in to agree with him: The poors have cell phones! They're fat! They just sell the food they get because they don't really need it!
     Reply
    If_I_Had_a_Poodle promoted this comment oudemia was starred oudemia was unstarred
    Image of If_I_Had_a_Poodle If_I_Had_a_Poodle
    11/29/09

    @oudemia: The poors also have electricity and running water. Some would take that away from them, too.
     Reply
    If_I_Had_a_Poodle was starred If_I_Had_a_Poodle was unstarred
    Image of oudemia oudemia
    11/29/09

    @If_I_Had_a_Poodle: And televisions! Color televisions!
     Reply
    oudemia was starred oudemia was unstarred
    Image of If_I_Had_a_Poodle If_I_Had_a_Poodle
    11/29/09

    @oudemia: With more than one channel!
     Reply
    If_I_Had_a_Poodle was starred If_I_Had_a_Poodle was unstarred
    Image of willwriteforfood willwriteforfood
    11/29/09

    @oudemia: Oh god. My bf's mother sent him a vile email chain complaining about a government-funded program that gives cheap cell phones to poor people. She was appalled and made some insane extrapolation that so many poors (in her infinite wisdom, she knew this for a fact) had cable television, so they didn't deserve cell phones too.
     Reply
    willwriteforfood was starred willwriteforfood was unstarred
    Image of booge booge
    11/29/09

    In reply to The Disconcerting Reality of Food Stamp America
    [www.fns.usda.gov]

    Jesus, the general guidelines are really low. $28,668 gross for a family of four?

    People should eat. Especially little people who didn't have a say in this whole deal so they don't get rickets and scurvy and beri beri.

    Maybe they shouldn't have had those kids--well, why is that any of my fucking concern? Do I want people all up in my womb, telling my ass how to breed? No. Then case closed.

    Eugenicists can go fuck themselves and roll around in some Little Debbie Snack Cakes or Beluga caviar or American pie or whatever they eat with all the food and judgment and money and power and smug American Freedom they have, because they aren't in this shitty predicament.
     Reply
    If_I_Had_a_Poodle promoted this comment booge was starred booge was unstarred
    Image of If_I_Had_a_Poodle If_I_Had_a_Poodle
    11/29/09

    @booge: And even if people don't like the parents or their choices or can't see that they could get dealt the same shitty cards in life, what about the children? Just let them starve?
     Reply
    If_I_Had_a_Poodle was starred If_I_Had_a_Poodle was unstarred
    Image of CrayonSmoothie CrayonSmoothie
    11/29/09

    @booge: "People should eat. Especially little people who didn't have a say in this whole deal so they don't get rickets and scurvy and beri beri."

    And so they can concentrate in school and get an education so they can grow up and become engineers or doctors and maybe make my life better by inventing some new technology or curing me if I'm sick.

    That's the kind of selfish I subscribe too.
     Reply
    Wrapitup promoted this comment Edited by CrayonSmoothie at 11/29/09 8:32 PM CrayonSmoothie was starred CrayonSmoothie was unstarred
    Image of Lysergic Asset Lysergic Asset
    11/29/09

    @booge: As someone who grew up in NYC living in (government cheese and powdered milk) poverty for a couple years in my early childhood, I salute you from the bottom of my heart for the intent and effectiveness of this comment.
     Reply
    Lysergic Asset was starred Lysergic Asset was unstarred
    Image of booge booge
    11/29/09

    @If_I_Had_a_Poodle: Well, didn't Jesus teach us to love one another, unless we didn't want to, because we felt superior? Then, fuck 'em and their fucking poor ass kids. They can shoplift or something. I think that's in the Gospel According to Supercilious.
     Reply
    booge was starred booge was unstarred
    Image of If_I_Had_a_Poodle If_I_Had_a_Poodle
    11/29/09

    @booge: Yes, that would be Republican Jesus.
     Reply
    If_I_Had_a_Poodle was starred If_I_Had_a_Poodle was unstarred
    Image of If_I_Had_a_Poodle If_I_Had_a_Poodle
    11/29/09

    @Lysergic Asset: I already liked and admired you. Now, more. Not many people are able to climb past where they started. Upward mobility is pretty much a lie -- poor neighborhood = poor schools = doomed children.
     Reply
    If_I_Had_a_Poodle was starred If_I_Had_a_Poodle was unstarred
    Image of Lysergic Asset Lysergic Asset
    11/29/09

    @If_I_Had_a_Poodle: I've been broke, but I've never been poor. I live in a one-bedroom house in a dusty rural Mexican pueblo with my boyfriend and two dogs and I am one of the happiest people I've ever known. Upward mobility is possible, if you're defining wealth as something that is nurtured within.
     Reply
    Lysergic Asset was starred Lysergic Asset was unstarred
    Image of If_I_Had_a_Poodle If_I_Had_a_Poodle
    11/29/09

    @Lysergic Asset: You so rock. I was never happier than when I was a poor starving ink stained wretch living in a 1.5 room studio and working for a wire service and believing that the future was open before me. It was, but it turned out to be a different one than I imagined -- one that hadn't been invented yet, but is just coming into its own now
     Reply
    If_I_Had_a_Poodle was starred If_I_Had_a_Poodle was unstarred
    Image of Lysergic Asset Lysergic Asset
    11/29/09

    @If_I_Had_a_Poodle: Good for you. To borrow part of a line from ee cummings, "Here is the deepest secret no one knows: happiness doesn't cost any money." But you've gotta not be starving to be able to see this.
     Reply
    Lysergic Asset was starred Lysergic Asset was unstarred
    Image of allyzay allyzay
    11/29/09

    @booge: On the whole "OMG how can poor people have CHILDREN how selfish!" tip that you hear all the time, let's all just be reminded that it costs money to have access to contraception, family planning, abortion, etc! Are the poor just not allowed to have sex ever too? The arguments really are so deeply messed up if you think about it - they're against feeding these people, they're against allowing basic access to health care services (such as family planning services), they're against meaningful education reform, housing services, etc etc etc, and then lambast these people for failing to succeed in these circumstances. It's insane!
     Reply
    allyzay was starred allyzay was unstarred
    Image of ParahSalin ParahSalin
    12:21 AM

    @Lysergic Asset: JK Rowling spent a few years on the dole too. It's a shame she had all that free time to write those Harry Potter stories instead of working the pole in a strip club like the other single mothers. Of course I always forget that her evil books are about witchcraft and devil stuff and a good Christian woman like myself shouldn't even be discussing them. I suspect her "me time" has payed for itself in spades with the Harry Potter-industrial-entertainment complex pulling in God knows how many bazillions in tax revenues.
     Reply
    Lysergic Asset promoted this comment ParahSalin was starred ParahSalin was unstarred
    Image of ParahSalin ParahSalin
    12:24 AM

    @allyzay: I for one am tired of molly coddling the poor. We all know that if we give them money they'll just spend it on food and clothes and booze....wait...that's what I spend my money on.
     Reply
    If_I_Had_a_Poodle promoted this comment ParahSalin was starred ParahSalin was unstarred
    Image of Lysergic Asset Lysergic Asset
    12:40 AM

    @ParahSalin: Contrast JK Rowling (awesome writer, formerly a single Mom on welfare) with Steffoneigh Meyer (shitty writer, formerly a comfortable suburban housewife) and you could conclude that poverty is good for the creative spirit.

    Also: I suspect that you are the type of Christian that Jesus would actually want to come back for.
     Reply
    Lysergic Asset was starred Lysergic Asset was unstarred
    Image of Better to Eat You With Better to Eat You With
    01:19 AM

    @If_I_Had_a_Poodle: It's funny where people go from these beginnings. My husband and I live pretty happily on a fairly modest budget. My sister has to have everything new every season and doesn't care where the money comes from. My response to getting the electricity shut off a couple of times a year as a kid was to learn to budget; hers was to do everything she could to make sure no one ever knows how poor we used to be. Both make a kind of sense.
     Reply
    If_I_Had_a_Poodle promoted this comment Edited by Better to Eat You With at 11/30/09 1:20 AM Better to Eat You With was starred Better to Eat You With was unstarred
    Image of If_I_Had_a_Poodle If_I_Had_a_Poodle
    07:29 AM

    @Better to Eat You With: Sounds right. Happens with those born and raised across the spectrum. xxoo.
     Reply
    If_I_Had_a_Poodle was starred If_I_Had_a_Poodle was unstarred
    Earlier discussions Other discussions Show all discussions Show featured discussions only Start a new discussion

Login

Enter your username and password.

Please enter a username.
Please enter your password.
logging in
Login via Facebook | Sign Up | Forgot Password?

Reset Password

Please enter your email address to have your password reset.

Please enter your email address.
Please enter a valid email address.
requesting password reset

Register

Registering will give you a user profile and the ability to add other users as friends. To become a commenter, however, you need to audition.

Want to know more? Consult the Comment FAQ and legal terms.

Please enter a username.
Please enter a password.
Please confirm your password.
Passwords are not identical.
Please enter a valid email address.
registration sent, waiting for reply

Submit Your Comment

You don't need to login to comment. Just enter your email address below.

See how your address will be displayed in the Comment FAQ.

Please enter a valid email address.
Please enter a valid email address.
logging in

Login with your Facebook or Gawker account.

Sign up here.



  • Archives
  • About
  • Advertising
  • Legal
  • Help
  • Report a Bug
  • FAQ
Original material is licensed under a Creative Commons License permitting non-commercial sharing with attribution.