sorrybottanica

posts about #sorrybottanica more →
I Hate Your 90s: N+1 Discussion Panel Ruins My Favorite Decade

Your version of Internet Explorer is not supported. Please upgrade to the most recent version in order to view comments.

Dsmvwl Admin Promote to frontpage Approve user Ban user ×

610Dean
05/17/09

In reply to I Hate Your 90s: N+1 Discussion Panel Ruins My Favorite Decade
Lame. Hootie and the Blowfish dont get any love?????
Reply

610Dean was starred 610Dean was unstarred

Phyllis Nefler
05/17/09

@610Dean: GOOD CALL.
Reply

Phyllis Nefler was starred Phyllis Nefler was unstarred

contains_hot_liquid
05/17/09

In reply to I Hate Your 90s: N+1 Discussion Panel Ruins My Favorite Decade
I hooked up with Emily during college, but it was not, alas, to "Say Goodbye". It was to silence. And the snores of the boy sleeping the room next door.
Reply

Solomon Grundy
05/17/09

@contains_hot_liquid: Would you describe yourself as a male or a female?
Reply

Solomon Grundy was starred Solomon Grundy was unstarred

contains_hot_liquid
05/17/09

@Solomon Grundy: Yes I would.
Reply

contains_hot_liquid
05/17/09

@contains_hot_liquid: Oh. Male.
Reply

labyrinthine IS DOING THIS
05/17/09

@contains_hot_liquid: even though I KNEW the DMB clip was posted above, I still thought "to silence" meant "to shut her up".
Reply

contains_hot_liquid
05/17/09

@labyrinthine: Ha. I should have left off that last sentence.
Reply

phlox✔
05/17/09

In reply to I Hate Your 90s: N+1 Discussion Panel Ruins My Favorite Decade
I did get my first computer in the 90s. Kind of a touchstone for me at least.
Also, Foster, if you got caught/ejected for putting your own booze in a bar drink, I'm not sure that your alcoholic skillz are up to snuff.
Practice at home for best results.
Reply

phlox✔ was starred phlox✔ was unstarred

ContactAllergy
05/16/09

In reply to I Hate Your 90s: N+1 Discussion Panel Ruins My Favorite Decade
Fine, I'll play the race card. That is the whitest list of pop-cultural touchstones. No Tupac/Biggie? No OJ Simpson? Nothing about the mainstreaming of hip hop culture? Give me a break. Maybe its because I spent a hefty chunk of the 90s at a black college where "Friends" was more likely to conjure up the classic hit by Whodini than Must See TV, but the 90s described above sounds nothing like the 90s I knew.
Reply

ContactAllergy was starred ContactAllergy was unstarred

skahammer
05/16/09

@ContactAllergy: Excellent point, this.

I doubt anyone would seriously argue that was a major -- perhaps the major -- feature of the decade in pop culture. I wonder what individual artifacts one would point to as illustrations. Some good discussions there, I'll bet.
Reply

skahammer was starred skahammer was unstarred

Foster Kamer
05/17/09

@ContactAllergy: Okay, concession - Biggie was talked about, but Tupac (and both Biggie and Tupac's shootings!) were generally glazed over. A little Public Enemy here, a little Wu-Tang there. But Grief did say that he once went to a Wu-Tang concert, though he ended up there only because he was going to see Rage Against The Machine. In retrospect, there might've been no greater thrill and worse moment than hearing Grief talk about the 36 Chambers. @HamiltonNolan would've had a coronary.
Reply

Foster Kamer was starred Foster Kamer was unstarred

Phyllis Nefler
05/17/09

@ContactAllergy: They talked about Public Enemy and the Wu Tang Clan, if that makes you feel any better. Oh, and Emily Gould referenced those oversized t-shirts with Tweety Bird dressed like a rapper, so.
Reply

Phyllis Nefler was starred Phyllis Nefler was unstarred

Phyllis Nefler
05/17/09

@Foster Kamer: Also there was no Snoop. :(
Reply

Phyllis Nefler was starred Phyllis Nefler was unstarred

contains_hot_liquid
05/17/09

@Foster Kamer: I went to that concert too! It was one of my first disappointments...
Reply

T.A.N.
05/17/09

@ContactAllergy: Yeah, this can't be overstated in the context of this post. From the reality show television, to advertising, to pop music, ignoring hip hop is sort of criminal. criminally annoying, at least.

i wasn't there though.
Reply

T.A.N. was starred T.A.N. was unstarred

southernbitch
05/17/09

@T.A.N.: maybe because im sort of a social worker who studied political science, i tend to look at the 90s and the culture therein as a reflection of the politics. so i find it strange that there are some glaring omissions- namely rodney king, welfare reform, and the rise of the christian right. not to mention seattle 1999. im just bored by people sitting around talking about sassy magazine as a huge cultural touchstone while ignoring some much larger things- waco, anyone? timothy mcveigh? the unabomber? far more interesting in retrospect than nirvana, sorry. and im saying that from the point of someone who still plays nirvana records on a regular basis.
Reply

southernbitch was starred southernbitch was unstarred

skahammer
05/17/09

@southernbitch: I'll see your Rodney King, welfare reform, and Christian right and raise you an OJ, a Lewinsky, and a Perot.

While I agree this one-upmanship is kind of fun, I don't think prescriptivism is the name of the game here. I suggest that inclusivity and descriptivism are probably better approaches to an amorphous, artificial topic like a decade.

So if Nirvana and Sassy are what you remember first from the Nineties, I'm interested enough to hear your explanation as to why. Same for Rodney King and welfare reform.

(Although descriptivism or no, the omission of the mainstreaming of hip-hop is pretty glaring, no doubt about that.)
Reply

skahammer was starred skahammer was unstarred

southernbitch
05/17/09

@skahammer: i think rodney king and welfare reform weigh heavily on my mind most likely because i work in lower income black communities, where the conversations tend to be mostly about racism, violence, and poverty. so ive started to view american culture through that lens.
Reply

southernbitch was starred southernbitch was unstarred

Roithamer
05/17/09

@skahammer: Rodney King, OJ, Lewinsky, Perot (and welfare reform due to an audience question): THESE ARE THE THINGS THAT THEY TALKED ABOUT. You just wouldn't know it from this post....
Reply

Roithamer was starred Roithamer was unstarred

Pope John Peeps II
05/18/09

@ContactAllergy: Wasn't the panel comprised of white people? Wouldn't it therefore be inappropriate to talk about black cultural touchstones?

What are you complaining about, exactly?
Reply

Pope John Peeps II was starred

skahammer
05/18/09

@Roithamer: Ah! Noted.
Reply

skahammer was starred skahammer was unstarred

Melissa Gira Grant
05/16/09

In reply to I Hate Your 90s: N+1 Discussion Panel Ruins My Favorite Decade
I say we wander from bar to bar demanding recourse from one bar one time kicking you out! Take our rage to the streets against the machines of loving grace! My friend Goo says PU!
Reply

Melissa Gira Grant was starred

Baroness
05/16/09

In reply to I Hate Your 90s: N+1 Discussion Panel Ruins My Favorite Decade
The thing that strikes me, is that the 90's started by being intensely self-aware- Douglas Coupland's Generation X came out in 1991, and was chock-full of mockery for the age that was fresh at the time. I remember everyone I knew rolling their eyes at the term "grunge", and as great as Nirvana was, anyone who constantly refers to them as a cultural lodestone of the 90's - well, I guess they got their credentials via subscription to Rolling Stone. They were a respected , interesting band when Cobain had an intact skull, but it took his suicide to make people misremember in retrospect how Nirvana was Beatlesque in cultural influence. Uh, no, they absolutely weren't. It's dumb VH1 retrospection to say they were.

The 90's was already constantly mocking itself in real time, I don't know how this dumb panel gets to condescend (n+1!-duh) to an entire decade. Did anyone mention how electronic music became dominant in Europe? Or Britpop? It sounds like the people on the panel feel qualified to judge because they were alive then, or something. But what idiotic tropes they're discussing- mostly it seems, what was on US television then, that they remember.

And no 25 year-old should be discussing the 90's, sit down, son.
Reply

Baroness was starred Baroness was unstarred

jasonelias
05/16/09

@Baroness: The 90s don't bare much reflection now. So much of the decade is still with us, it's not like it's 1993 and we're thinking about 1979. The times haven't changed all that much. Plus, I thought we covered this stuff while the '90s were going on. I'm thinking it was VH1, Molly Culver, something...

Now the '80s? I'd love to examine why that decade was so weird. Not all that interested in the '90s.
Reply

jasonelias was starred jasonelias was unstarred

Awesome X
05/17/09

@Baroness: Azerrad is an odd choice for a 90s panel. I can't recall a single relevant word he's written on a topic that existed beyond the year 1994. He's much more of an 80s expert, "Our Band Could Be Your Life" topical stuff. What does he know of Neutral Milk Hotel, Flaming Lips, Wu Tang Clan, ect.? Nirvana was great for dislodging tasteless pop and hair metal from mainstream charts, but that's its legacy. If anything, Nirvana ended the 80s, but it hardly encapsulates the 90s.

Also, Nirvana's music was mostly awful. Simple punk guitar riffs with punks' funny/fun/thoughtful lyrics substituted for complete gibberish. What bullshit.
Reply

Awesome X was starred Awesome X was unstarred

Steve Holt's Mother Part Deux
05/16/09

In reply to I Hate Your 90s: N+1 Discussion Panel Ruins My Favorite Decade
U.S. Dept. Of Retro Warns: 'We May Be Running Out Of Past'

[www.theonion.com]
Reply

HiredGoons
05/16/09

In reply to I Hate Your 90s: N+1 Discussion Panel Ruins My Favorite Decade
Everything one might need to know about the '90s can be found at any Spencer's Gifts.
Reply

HiredGoons was starred HiredGoons was unstarred

belltolls
05/16/09

In reply to I Hate Your 90s: N+1 Discussion Panel Ruins My Favorite Decade
Well you know what they say about the 90s, "If you can remember it, you were likely there." It's also interesting NOBODY claims to have been at Woodstock II.
Reply

belltolls was starred belltolls was unstarred

ADismalScience
05/16/09

In reply to I Hate Your 90s: N+1 Discussion Panel Ruins My Favorite Decade
It used to be that scribes and chronologists would have similar (though less douchey) panel discussions. Ultimately, they would come to some form of consensus on the relevant highlights of an era and go write a history. For this act, they would be revered.

I'm kind of glad we've changed our minds on that.
Reply

ADismalScience was starred ADismalScience was unstarred

Dickdogfood
05/16/09

@ADismalScience: Dis, I can't even tell if you're kidding.
Reply

Dickdogfood was starred Dickdogfood was unstarred

labyrinthine IS DOING THIS
05/16/09

In reply to I Hate Your 90s: N+1 Discussion Panel Ruins My Favorite Decade
@Foster Kamer: and next year, these same dickbags will do the same thing for the first decade of the 2000s, and they'll be even less relevant. if anyone even goes, it'll be the speakers droning on about SARS and fucking Coldplay and some twat twenty-something will maybe look up from their texting long enough to say "dude, Eddie Vedder called from the '90s and he still wants his fucking flannel back".
Reply

nathanst
05/16/09

@labyrinthine: The 90's condemned the 80's, the 80's the 70's and etc.

It's like they're giving the fashionistas a handjob with their doodoo holes. Only after a decade is condemned can it then be reintroduced as retro.
Reply

nathanst was starred nathanst was unstarred

labyrinthine IS DOING THIS
05/16/09

@nathanst: hmm. regarding fashion: did this decade have any standout fashion that will be regurgitated in thirty years, or was it all just the bell bottoms/Hypercolor trash of the '70s and '80s?

I don't know; hell, I'm not into fashion at all, which to some people is ZOMGSHOCKING for a female, I'm sure. but it's just interesting. it's like the world has run out of ideas, so we have to rerun everything with a new hat a la Malibu Stacey instead.
Reply

Dickdogfood
05/16/09

@labyrinthine: Perhaps the most important 90s contribution to prêt-à-porter fashion: corporate casual.
Reply

Dickdogfood was starred Dickdogfood was unstarred

Lizawithazee
05/17/09

@labyrinthine: To me, the '90s fashion gestalt was minimalism (Jill Sanders, Helmut Lang, all those Dutch designers, Prada to a degree) to counter the over-the-top vibe of Versace and Gucci once Tom Ford joined them.

They didn't talk about email? That was the "killer app" of '90s, wasn't it? Actually, perhaps "killer app" sums up the '90s.
Reply

Lizawithazee was starred Lizawithazee was unstarred

nathanst
05/16/09

In reply to I Hate Your 90s: N+1 Discussion Panel Ruins My Favorite Decade
Your 90's can suck my 90's dick for all I care.

also Fight Club

also the Matrix and American Beauty and hundred more cultural items. Don't make me whip out video games because I will.
Reply

nathanst was starred nathanst was unstarred

labyrinthine IS DOING THIS
05/16/09

@nathanst: do it, do it! I love me some video games.
Reply

nathanst
05/16/09

@labyrinthine:

Birth of the Warcraft, Command and Conquer, Smash Bros and Mariokart series to start.

All of which have dominant places in the 00's marketplace.
Reply

nathanst was starred nathanst was unstarred

Alys Brangwin has a huge talent
05/17/09

@nathanst: Starcraft too!
Reply

Dickdogfood
05/16/09

In reply to I Hate Your 90s: N+1 Discussion Panel Ruins My Favorite Decade
I love popcult wankery like nobody's business, and yet this still sounds like icepick-to-the-ear brainnoise. I mean, if you think the 90s is a subject perfectly suitable for an hour-plus panel discussion, THEN YOU WEREN'T THERE, MAN.
Reply

Dickdogfood was starred Dickdogfood was unstarred

labyrinthine IS DOING THIS
05/16/09

@Dickdogfood: same here. I will watch any VH1 I Love the ... any time it's on, but I'mm be damned if I go listen to some...Nirvana scholar?! seriously? god, if I ever found myself trapped in a room with that guy, he'd better pray that I'm not packing a concealed weapon.
Reply

Dickdogfood
05/16/09

@labyrinthine: I really wouldn't call Azerrad a Nirvana scholar per se, not the way some people are Madonna scholars: he's more just a guy who wrote a sorta-kinda authorized bio about the band when Cobain was still alive.
Reply

Dickdogfood was starred Dickdogfood was unstarred

i'm a bottle
05/16/09

In reply to I Hate Your 90s: N+1 Discussion Panel Ruins My Favorite Decade
Foster, if there happens to be a copy of the 15th edition of the Chicago Manual of Style somewhere in the office, then do me a favor look at 9.37.
Reply

i'm a bottle was starred i'm a bottle was unstarred

labyrinthine IS DOING THIS
05/16/09

@i'm a bottle: also, isn't 9.37 specifically "The first two decades of a century may not be expressed in numerals"? I mean, I get your point, but...meh. I lost my momentum. it's the weekend and it's only slightly more difficult to get bent out of shape about this stuff. :)
Reply

i'm a bottle
05/16/09

@labyrinthine: Yeah, it says that but I had this in mind: "No apostrophe appears between the year and the s."
Reply

i'm a bottle was starred i'm a bottle was unstarred

Foster Kamer
05/16/09

@i'm a bottle: in all fairness, I don't give a shit about style manuals. that being said, as an editor, some shit drives me crazy, too. fixed, for you.
Reply

Foster Kamer was starred Foster Kamer was unstarred

i'm a bottle
05/16/09

@i'm a bottle: Sweet!
Reply

i'm a bottle was starred i'm a bottle was unstarred

skahammer
05/16/09

@i'm a bottle: I don't know about you, but I come to Gawker for the rapid turnaround and unvarnished commentary.

For perfect punctuation, on the other hand, I rely on sources that hire actual jerkoff copy editors.

Signed, Onetime Jerkoff Copy Editor
Reply

skahammer was starred skahammer was unstarred

i'm a bottle
05/16/09

@skahammer: @labyrinthine: @Foster Kamer: That apostrophe was taunting me. It was in the headline. Can't we just forget about it now though and move on?
Reply

i'm a bottle was starred i'm a bottle was unstarred

labyrinthine IS DOING THIS
05/16/09

In reply to I Hate Your 90s: N+1 Discussion Panel Ruins My Favorite Decade
god. it sounds like the Algonquin Douche Table.
Reply

Foster Kamer
05/16/09

@labyrinthine: Nice. Noel Coward would be proud of you right now.
Reply

Foster Kamer was starred Foster Kamer was unstarred

Earlier discussions Other discussions Show all discussions Show featured discussions only Start a new discussion

#sorrybottanica

Gawker

SUBSCRIBE TO Gawker

I Hate Your 90s: N+1 Discussion Panel Ruins My Favorite Decade

Login

Reset Password

Register

Submit Your Comment