• Profile logout login

#thepope#discussed

Gawker

Share Cancel
   
Upload an image | Add an image URL
×

logging in
  • FAQ. Include # before tag:
  • #tips,
  • #stalker,
  • #opencaption,
  • #internalmemos,
  • etc.

New York, 2:02 PM
Tue Dec 8
56 posts in the last 24 hours

Team

Tip Your Editors:

Tipline: 646-214-8138

Editor-in-Chief:
Gabriel Snyder |

West Coast Editor:
Richard Rushfield |

Contributing Editors:

Valleywag:
Ryan Tate |

Media:
Hamilton Nolan |

Politics:
Alex Pareene |

Investigations:
John Cook |

Entertainment:
Brian Moylan |

Nights:
Adrian Chen |
Azaria Jagger |
Ravi Somaiya |

Weekends:
Foster Kamer |

Video Editor:
Richard Blakeley |

SUBSCRIBE TO Gawker RSS

New: Breaking news and daily top stories via email
4260 Subscribers
Gawker
  • Your version of Internet Explorer is not supported. Please upgrade to the most recent version in order to view comments.
    Dsmvwl  Admin  Promote to frontpage Approve user Ban user ×
    Image of JennaW JennaW
    10/11/09

    In reply to Sarah Silverman's Latest Attempt At Viral Infamy: Saving The World
    Love her. I know she's not to everyone's taste, but the people who say, "She's just not that funny" are themselves HILARIOUS to me! Mostly because I imagine those people as effete, sexless Victorian men quietly shocked by women, children, and servants of any gender who dare to express opinions. Hee.
     Reply
    JennaW was starred JennaW was unstarred
    Image of WackoJacko WackoJacko
    10/11/09

    In reply to Sarah Silverman's Latest Attempt At Viral Infamy: Saving The World
    Why doesn't this woman make me laugh? Her manner and constant, consistent mugging suggests I should find her funny and yet I don't. I don't get it.
     Reply
    WackoJacko was starred WackoJacko was unstarred
    Image of Uncle_Billy_Slumming Uncle_Billy_Slumming
    10/11/09

    In reply to Sarah Silverman's Latest Attempt At Viral Infamy: Saving The World
    Sarah, meet me tomorrow morning at Vivian's in Studio City at about 9:00? I want to work with you on a strategy to keep you from getting extremely bitter in old age.
     Reply
    Uncle_Billy_Slumming was starred Uncle_Billy_Slumming was unstarred
    Image of waltzngmatlda waltzngmatlda
    10/11/09

    In reply to Sarah Silverman's Latest Attempt At Viral Infamy: Saving The World
    sure, sarah! let's sell the vatican. right after you sell israel.
     Reply
    Cynical Media Bitch promoted this comment waltzngmatlda was starred waltzngmatlda was unstarred
    Image of Glib and Bitchy Glib and Bitchy
    10/11/09

    In reply to Sarah Silverman's Latest Attempt At Viral Infamy: Saving The World
    Vatican humor, 1960s-style.
     Reply
    Glib and Bitchy was starred Glib and Bitchy was unstarred
    Image of VeeKaChu VeeKaChu
    10/11/09

    @Glib and Bitchy: I had the word 'transubstantiate' in my vocabulary when I was 6 or 7, thanks to that song. Didn't know what it meant, but it sounded really hip when he sang it.

    I'm pretty sure it was the songs of Tom Lehrer that set me on the path to DFH-style liberalism in the sixties. He was a genius, and funny as fuck.
     Reply
    Glib and Bitchy promoted this comment VeeKaChu was starred VeeKaChu was unstarred
    Image of Glib and Bitchy Glib and Bitchy
    10/11/09

    @VeeKaChu: And "genuflect." Not something that came up a lot in Sunday School.
     Reply
    Glib and Bitchy was starred Glib and Bitchy was unstarred
    Image of Cynical Media Bitch Cynical Media Bitch
    10/12/09

    @Glib and Bitchy: You sound like you're a Presbyterian or something.
     Reply
    Cynical Media Bitch was starred Cynical Media Bitch was unstarred
    Image of yourfriendandneighbor yourfriendandneighbor
    10/11/09

    In reply to Sarah Silverman's Latest Attempt At Viral Infamy: Saving The World
    My name is yourfriendandneighbor and I approve of this message.
     Reply
    yourfriendandneighbor was starred yourfriendandneighbor was unstarred
    Image of beugenius beugenius
    10/11/09

    In reply to Sarah Silverman's Latest Attempt At Viral Infamy: Saving The World
    I'm a huge Sarah fan but I'm getting tired of Catholic bashing. If I (brought up catholic) were to make jokes about jewish religion in any way, I would be considered a racist and an anti-semite. Jewish comedians can shit on anybody and are immune from backlash. Especially if they bring up the "H" bomb. This video's underlying message is that Catholics and the church don't give a shit about starving people. This joke implies a lot of bad things about Catholics. Maybe Sarah is using irony to make some point here but this kind of humor just taps into what really divides people. It actually crosses the line and makes me mad that she would joke that Catholics are willing to see people starve in Africa. I just see double standard. I could never make jokes about a Jewish holy figure or monument. Have any jewish religious figures, or organizations, ever helped non jewish people in Africa? Probably, but I'm going to guess that a LOT more catholics have. There are probably thousands of people working in Africa to help starving children. I'm going to guess that many or most are Christian or Catholic. I guess thats why this video from Sarah upsets me.
     Reply
    Cunning_Linguist promoted this comment Foster Kamer approved this comment beugenius was starred beugenius was unstarred
    Image of Cunning_Linguist Cunning_Linguist
    10/11/09

    @beugenius: She isn't making fun of Catholics, per se. She is making fun of the papacy.

    And arguing that Christian missionaries in Africa are without fault themselves is not only beside the point, but not necessarily true. It's thinly veiled religious imperialism.
     Reply
    Cunning_Linguist was starred Cunning_Linguist was unstarred
    Image of rajmahall rajmahall
    10/11/09

    @beugenius: I think that the fact that you refrain from jokes about Jewish holy figures likely has to do with the fact there is not a Jewish leader with the level of status afforded the Pope. If there were one living person even nominally in charge of all the Jews, I would tell you to please go nuts. Honestly, the idea of such a person seems so at odds with Jewish custom, it's not surprising Jewish comedians are fascinated enough to often go there.

    Also, considering that there exist over one billion Roman Catholics, and about 15 million Jews, I absolutely believe you when you say that more Catholics have done aid work. It would be embarrassing if they HADN'T done a lot more aid work.
     Reply
    SarahHeartburn promoted this comment rajmahall was starred rajmahall was unstarred
    Image of MyNameIsChris MyNameIsChris
    10/11/09

    @beugenius: Watch South Park. You can get all your zany Jew laughs there - I'm fairly sure.
     Reply
    MyNameIsChris was starred MyNameIsChris was unstarred
    Image of SarahHeartburn SarahHeartburn
    10/11/09

    @rajmahall: As a recovering Catholic myself, I think any religion whose CEO is a guy in a dress who disses gays, kisses airports and worst of all, claims to be infallible, deserves all the ribbing it can get.
     Reply
    SarahHeartburn was starred SarahHeartburn was unstarred
    Image of Glib and Bitchy Glib and Bitchy
    10/11/09

    @MyNameIsChris: Or here.
     Reply
    Glib and Bitchy was starred Glib and Bitchy was unstarred
    Image of gawkimo gawkimo
    10/12/09

    @beugenius: You don't HAVE to be Catholic to do good deeds. And Catholics have no monopoly on charity.

    There are plenty of secular charity orgs, like Oxfam and Doctors Without Borders that don't have weird fairy tale issues about birth control or using condoms to prevent the spread of infectious disease.

    And why a former Nazi Pope form Germany? Yes, I know, I know: he redeemed himself from a very brief period of being a member of the Third Reich.

    But in case anyone hasn't noticed: the Catholics are predominantly from the Third World and this last selection makes the Vatican look very post-colonial. It's a typical Old Europe paternal-colonial mentality that caused them to ensure an African or Latin American pope was off the table. I find that creepy.
     Reply
    Edited by gawkimo at 10/12/09 4:03 AM gawkimo was starred gawkimo was unstarred
    Image of seattlesue seattlesue
    10/12/09

    @beugenius: When you analyze it, comedy works when there is an underlying truth to it. SS's 'humor' is based on a lie, and therefore, not funny.
     Reply
    Cynical Media Bitch promoted this comment seattlesue was starred seattlesue was unstarred
    Image of Cynical Media Bitch Cynical Media Bitch
    10/12/09

    @Cunning_Linguist: Many Catholics forget that making fun of the papacy is hardly attacking Catholicism. And I agree with rajmahall, the idea of the Pope and the sovereign status of the Vatican provides endless joke fodder.

    The comedy routines that are most likely to make me laugh so hard that I cry are about the Church. The South Park episodes with "The Catholic Boat, the miraculous statue and the boys taking First Communion are priceless. I howl whenever I hear George Carlin, Cheech Marin, or Don Novello do their bits on the Church. Why? Because as a not-terribly-devout Catholic in the 21st Century, I'm the first to admit that we believe in, and practice, some crazy shit.
     Reply
    Cynical Media Bitch was starred Cynical Media Bitch was unstarred
    Image of Cynical Media Bitch Cynical Media Bitch
    10/12/09

    @gawkimo: How does the term "post-colonial" apply to a universal church?

    FYI, the Vatican bureaucracy doesn't elect the Pope, nor do the national churches; the College of Cardinals does that. The last time I looked, it was still a very Euro-American body, but depending on how long Benedict lives and who he appoints, that could change.

    You make it sound like Benedict volunteered to be a Nazi, when nothing could be further from the truth. The Third Reich wasn't a club to which one applied for membership; teenage boys were required to join the Hitler Youth. (The boys in the White Rose resistance group were also in the HJ.)

    It never ceases to amaze me that some people still haven't grasped this simple truth: the Third Reich was the legally-recognized government of Germany. By no stretch of the imagination does this excuse the evil of the Nazi leadership, but as I've said elsewhere, if you're going to make value judgements, at least understand some basic facts.
     Reply
    Cynical Media Bitch was starred Cynical Media Bitch was unstarred
    Image of Cynical Media Bitch Cynical Media Bitch
    10/12/09

    @seattlesue: What lie? Where? All I see is exaggeration, and that's an important component of funny.
     Reply
    Cynical Media Bitch was starred Cynical Media Bitch was unstarred
    Image of anonymousryan anonymousryan
    10/11/09

    In reply to Sarah Silverman's Latest Attempt At Viral Infamy: Saving The World
    Did her show get canceled?
     Reply
    PaisleyPajamas promoted this comment anonymousryan was starred anonymousryan was unstarred
    Image of PaisleyPajamas PaisleyPajamas
    10/11/09

    @anonymousryan: She announced on Real Time that the show returns in February.
     Reply
    PaisleyPajamas was starred PaisleyPajamas was unstarred
    Image of Richard Blakeley Richard Blakeley
    10/11/09

    In reply to Sarah Silverman's Latest Attempt At Viral Infamy: Saving The World
    Someone give her a Nobel Prize!
     Reply
    Richard Blakeley was starred Richard Blakeley was unstarred
    Image of Sneeze In Bed Sneeze In Bed
    10/11/09

    In reply to Sarah Silverman's Latest Attempt At Viral Infamy: Saving The World
    She makes a pretty excellent point.
     Reply
    Sneeze In Bed was starred Sneeze In Bed was unstarred
    Image of Calraigh Calraigh
    10/11/09

    @Sneeze In Bed: Agreed! I laughed heartily, I did.
     Reply
    Calraigh was starred Calraigh was unstarred
    Image of Swifter Swifter
    10/11/09

    In reply to Sarah Silverman's Latest Attempt At Viral Infamy: Saving The World
    We made her an honorary Lutheran.
     Reply
    Swifter was starred Swifter was unstarred
    Image of i'm a bottle i'm a bottle
    10/11/09

    In reply to Sarah Silverman's Latest Attempt At Viral Infamy: Saving The World
    It's not offensive, it's just not that funny.
     Reply
    i'm a bottle was starred i'm a bottle was unstarred
    Image of MiracleDrug MiracleDrug
    10/11/09

    @i'm a bottle: I dunno. I liked the image of the pope going down a waterslide.
     Reply
    Btwbfdimho promoted this comment MiracleDrug was starred MiracleDrug was unstarred
    Image of yourfriendandneighbor yourfriendandneighbor
    10/11/09

    @i'm a bottle: it's true. it's an old joke. i'm a lapsed Catholic and i've heard that criticism (about how rich the Church is) all my life. but this video is funny because of HOW she said it. Not the most hysterical thing I've ever seen. but, "you'll get all the pussy" was pretty funny.
     Reply
    yourfriendandneighbor was starred yourfriendandneighbor was unstarred
    Image of Mackintosh-Toffee Mackintosh-Toffee
    10/11/09

    @yourfriendandneighbor: on the other hand, i found all the pussy to be not that funny! the lead up was solid enough, but the pussy punch line was not the required pay off to make it work.

    i'm not offended either, i just don't find that funny.

    also, doesn't the US spend more than that on defense??

    logic was not her friend with this one.
     Reply
    Mackintosh-Toffee was starred Mackintosh-Toffee was unstarred
    Image of Btwbfdimho Btwbfdimho
    10/11/09

    @MiracleDrug:
     Reply
    Btwbfdimho was starred Btwbfdimho was unstarred
    Image of Novaload Novaload
    09/27/09

    In reply to God's Eight-Legged Operative Fails To Complete Reconnaissance Mission
    Arachna-Popia!
     Reply
    Novaload was starred Novaload was unstarred
    Image of Lucia Toledo Lucia Toledo
    09/27/09

    In reply to God's Eight-Legged Operative Fails To Complete Reconnaissance Mission
    Not a great pope, but a great performer.
     Reply
    Lucia Toledo was starred Lucia Toledo was unstarred
    Image of Mike Jahn Mike Jahn
    09/27/09

    In reply to God's Eight-Legged Operative Fails To Complete Reconnaissance Mission
    It's like when the fly went into that guy's mouth in "Raiders."
     Reply
    Mike Jahn was starred Mike Jahn was unstarred
    Earlier discussions Other discussions Show all discussions Show featured discussions only Start a new discussion

Login

Enter your username and password.

Please enter a username.
Please enter your password.
logging in
Login via Facebook | Sign Up | Forgot Password?

Reset Password

Please enter your email address to have your password reset.

Please enter your email address.
Please enter a valid email address.
requesting password reset

Register

Registering will give you a user profile and the ability to add other users as friends. To become a commenter, however, you need to audition.

Want to know more? Consult the Comment FAQ and legal terms.

Please enter a username.
Please enter a password.
Please confirm your password.
Passwords are not identical.
Please enter a valid email address.
registration sent, waiting for reply

Submit Your Comment

You don't need to login to comment. Just enter your email address below.

See how your address will be displayed in the Comment FAQ.

Please enter a valid email address.
Please enter a valid email address.
logging in

Login with your Facebook or Gawker account.

Sign up here.



  • Archives
  • About
  • Advertising
  • Legal
  • Help
  • Report a Bug
  • FAQ
Original material is licensed under a Creative Commons License permitting non-commercial sharing with attribution.