the reader - Gawker

posts about #thereader more →
Box Office Bump for Oscar Babies
Harvey Weinstein's Non-Comeback Comeback
Kate Winslet Hopes Oscar Can Vault Her Into Upper, Non-Nude Echelon Of Actresses
Why Yes, Ben Lyons WAS On 'The View' Today!
Harvey Weinstein Hopes You're Still Scared of Him
Harvey Weinstein Critically Wounds Four In Oscar Gunplay
'Milk,' 'The Reader' Flunk Wide-Release Test
Academy Allows Four 'Reader' Producers -- None Named 'Scott Rudin'
5 Plots And Subplots To Watch In This Year's Oscar Race
You Say 'Statutory Rape,' Kate Winslet Says 'Puppy Love'

Your version of Internet Explorer is not supported. Please upgrade to the most recent version in order to view comments.

Dsmvwl Admin Promote to frontpage Approve user Ban user ×

Inhaler
03/02/09

In reply to Box Office Bump for Oscar Babies
Had it not been for the avant garde production of 2 Girls 1 Cup, America might not have been so receptive to Slumdog's poo play. Let's give credit where credit is due.
Reply

Inhaler was starred Inhaler was unstarred

Ensconced
03/02/09

In reply to Box Office Bump for Oscar Babies
********SPOILER ALERT*********

Uh, you guys? Don't forget that he loses his brother at the exact moment as he wins the money. So I don't really see the cloying sentimentality you lot are referring to.

Is it perfect? No. But no American would have made this movie (well, not unless Hilary Duff was cast as the titular character WHICH, YES, WOULD BE AWESOME).
Reply

Ensconced was starred Ensconced was unstarred

pufflehuff
03/02/09

@Ensconced: Yes, Salim is such an interesting character - how do their paths diverge so greatly? And despite Salim doing some bad stuff, he almost always saves the more passive Jamal. Is there any justice? Not much. Jamal might have the money and the girl, but look at all he's lost, and he's clearly marked by it; why else would those memories have stuck with him?

The gameshow is kind of an elaborate conceit for trawling through the life of a horribly abused person born into poverty. If it's analysed too much, it falls apart, but I didn't hear anyone complaining when about that when Bruce Willis was dead all along.

The dance at the end is misjudged, tonally - I have no time for Bollywood conventions anyway - but I took it as almost a DVD extra. I mean, dead characters come back to life and start dancing. It's like those fake deleted scenes that play next to the end credits of Pixar films.
Reply

pufflehuff was starred pufflehuff was unstarred

Calraigh
03/01/09

In reply to Box Office Bump for Oscar Babies
Ann Caruso? Anything to David or D.J? And do you take your sunglasses off at every available opportunity?

I'm just spitballing here.
Reply

Calraigh was starred Calraigh was unstarred

HouseBunnny
03/01/09

In reply to Box Office Bump for Oscar Babies
Why pay 10 bucks when you can watch New York rapidly turn into Mumbai for free?
Reply

HouseBunnny was starred HouseBunnny was unstarred

LucilleMcGillicuddy
03/01/09

@Cindy_McCain:your remark and your screen-name are an excellent match.
Reply

Heywoodjablome
03/01/09

@LucilleMcGillicuddy: Both of yoru names are just great.
Reply

Heywoodjablome was starred Heywoodjablome was unstarred

LucilleMcGillicuddy
03/01/09

@Heywoodjablome: as is yours!
Reply

Wrapitup
03/01/09

@Cindy_McCain: Well if you want to keep attending your favorite Aryan Nation rallies, there's always Idaho. Your own private Idaho.
Reply

Wrapitup was starred Wrapitup was unstarred

VoxPopuli
03/01/09

In reply to Box Office Bump for Oscar Babies
Hey, a new writer (I think). Are you the new Defamer hire, Ann?
Reply

VoxPopuli was starred VoxPopuli was unstarred

BxgrlJeri
03/01/09

In reply to Box Office Bump for Oscar Babies
The movie smash of the year would be the Jonas brothers covered in poo. Now that is one I'd go to see.
Reply

BxgrlJeri was starred BxgrlJeri was unstarred

uptonogood
03/01/09

In reply to Box Office Bump for Oscar Babies
i'm still not sure where the "feel good" part of slumdog comes in. good movie on further reflection, still makes you feel like shit.
Reply

uptonogood was starred uptonogood was unstarred

pufflehuff
03/01/09

@uptonogood: Hearing the name "AMITABH BACHCHAN" now makes me feel like shit.

Also, yes.
Reply

pufflehuff was starred pufflehuff was unstarred

Niko Bellic
03/01/09

@uptonogood: Well, a nerdy loser gets a bag of cash and some hot chick, which (if you are a nerdy loser) are the two most "feel good" things in the world that you could think of. And what's a few kids blinded with acid so they can make better beggars in comparison to that? Everybody, dance now!
Reply

Niko Bellic was starred Niko Bellic was unstarred

gawkimo
03/01/09

@Niko Bellic: I don't understand the confusion people have when some refer to it as a "feel good" film: Guy gets money and girl at the end of the film, which ends with a Bollywood song-and-dance routine -- something that was already embellished in "Monsoon Wedding". This film is not just "feel-good" but also thoroughly American despite all the Subconty decoration.
Reply

gawkimo was starred gawkimo was unstarred

MrInBetween
03/01/09

@gawkimo: I agree with everything you wrote except the fact that Slumdog is "thoroughly American." It isn't. It's "thoroughly American, as imagined by a crew of cynical Brits."
Reply

MrInBetween was starred MrInBetween was unstarred

RoosiDesi
03/01/09

@gawkimo: Eh, in terms of storyline, it is thoroughly Indian as well.
Reply

RoosiDesi was starred RoosiDesi was unstarred

gawkimo
03/01/09

@MrInBetween: Same difference. You don't have to be American to make a film that depicts that all-American sense of optimism and predictable happy endings (guy gets girl and money, the end).
Reply

gawkimo was starred gawkimo was unstarred

gawkimo
03/01/09

@RoosiDesi: As I said, slapping on a Bollywood ending has already been done. As far the rest, it doesn't feel like a Bollywood film. I'm not saying it a bad film, I'm just saying it's feel good and American -- and IMO a bit overrated, but that's just me: I am allergic to precious and adorable things.
Reply

gawkimo was starred gawkimo was unstarred

RoosiDesi
03/01/09

@gawkimo: Agree with you on the overrated bit. And yes, it is American too. Which is why I said it is Indian "as well".

While watching it, I never felt that I am watching something non-Bollywood. It probably depends on one's film-watching history. I had read the book long before they thought of making this film, so that must have colored my perception as well.
Reply

RoosiDesi was starred RoosiDesi was unstarred

gawkimo
03/01/09

@RoosiDesi: ** Rushdie wrote in Britain's Guardian newspaper that the central feature of the film -- that a boy from the Mumbai slums manages to succeed on the Indian TV version of "Who Wants to Be a Millionaire" -- "beggars belief." **

I kinda see what Rushdie means. It's a fantasy film, but the fantasy isn't believable and the fantasy has no larger theme. It's not like this surreal concept has any greater meaning (game show + Third World slum = WHAT? What exactly is the metaphor here?). It's just seems like a vehicle for some amazing cinematography (that's what I liked about it) and ultimately its just another cheesy love story about overcoming challenges, getting the girl and getting rich.

And as far as Oscar nods are concerned: Lord of the Rings II got like 896 Oscar statues. That movie was like watching somebody else play a video game.
Reply

gawkimo was starred gawkimo was unstarred

Tremonius
03/01/09

In reply to Box Office Bump for Oscar Babies
I read that, because of the great uproar and general distress over the pitiful living arrangement spotlit by the Oscar broadcast, Mickey Rourke was allowed to move out of his South Central shopping crate.
Reply

Tremonius was starred Tremonius was unstarred

Losin_it
02/24/09

In reply to Harvey Weinstein's Non-Comeback Comeback
Absolutely the only thing that can save the Weinstein empire now is to make another Kevin Smith flick.
Reply

Losin_it was starred Losin_it was unstarred

bess marvin, girl detective
02/24/09

In reply to Harvey Weinstein's Non-Comeback Comeback
What exactly does Harvey do to get these Academy to vote for his people? I would really like to know? Does he buy them cars, houses, hookers, blow? Does he threatens their family? Also, even if he did, does he hover over their shoulders when they vote. Everyone has free will and there is no excuse for voting Paltrow or Crash in for anything. I still blame the voting idiots whose ignorance goes way back before Weinstein was a major player, I mean how else can you explain Roberto Benigni?
Reply

NoelleBlue
02/23/09

In reply to Harvey Weinstein's Non-Comeback Comeback
'isn't' quite as diffusely snarky
Reply

NoelleBlue was starred NoelleBlue was unstarred

Juancho
02/23/09

In reply to Harvey Weinstein's Non-Comeback Comeback
STV, this was a fine piece of work!
Reply

Juancho was starred Juancho was unstarred

NoWireHangers
02/23/09

@Juancho: It is. I'm trying to soak up all the Seth, Kyle, and STV I can this week.

WHY, DENTON, WHY?!?!?!!11?/?akl ;djacx.z.......
Reply

NoWireHangers was starred NoWireHangers was unstarred

NoelleBlue
02/23/09

@NoWireHangers: Indeed. I might not always agree with Defamer writers on movies, but I think it's some of the best writing on the Gawker network by far, and the most on-subject. (And I LOVE disagreeing with people on movies, spice of life!)

Maybe that's part of the problem - it is quite as diffusely snarky as Gawker, and maybe someone thought the tone didn't 'match', so they decided to simply 'absorb'. Sigh. May you all find emerald green pastures worthy of your talents and passions.
Reply

NoelleBlue was starred NoelleBlue was unstarred

kookla
02/23/09

@Juancho:

@NoWireHangers: Hold me, I'm scared!!!
Reply

kookla was starred kookla was unstarred

MisterHippity
02/23/09

In reply to Harvey Weinstein's Non-Comeback Comeback
Why no mention of his colossal fuckup with Project Runway?

That whole sorry tale pretty much puts the final nail in coffin of the "Weinstein as "canny businessman" myth.
Reply

MisterHippity was starred MisterHippity was unstarred

unclevanya
02/23/09

@MisterHippity: Indeed. The rest of the industry/media should blackball him until he fesses up to be a greedy bastard for striking the deal with Lifetime without talking to NBCU first. Then take his lumps, strike a new deal wherever it lands, apologize to PR fans, and then shut up and go back to making movies nobody wants to see.
Reply

unclevanya was starred unclevanya was unstarred

checkyaself
02/23/09

In reply to Harvey Weinstein's Non-Comeback Comeback
I have never heard about Mr. Weinstein until this year and I can't stand him.

He got Paltrow the Oscar over Blanchett in 1999 along with Shakespeare in Love over every other nominated movie from 1999, he also got Crash over Brokeback Mountain.

If anyone else has more they'd like to name please feel free.

Now it's not that these movies or performances were bad it is that they won from Harvey's campaigning not because they were the best of the bunch.
Reply

checkyaself was starred checkyaself was unstarred

MCU
02/24/09

@checkyaself: So first we get the news about Defamer being dissolved into the Gawker vat. And then immediately we get something like "I have never heard about Mr. Weinstein until this year".

This is by no means a personal poke, my dear checkyaself, but: I guess we'll have to look elsewhere for the lowdown on industry rumblings from inside the UTA mailroom, hmm?
Reply

MCU was starred MCU was unstarred

sassenach
02/10/09

In reply to Harvey Weinstein Hopes You're Still Scared of Him
Billy the Kid was a pedantic schlub?
Reply

sassenach was starred sassenach was unstarred

Uncle_Billy_Slumming
02/10/09

@sassenach:

*Is* a pedantic schlub. (That's fun to write)

I think Richard has a thing for Billy's. Ok, off to talk to some Scientologists.
Reply

Earlier discussions Other discussions Show all discussions Show featured discussions only Start a new discussion

SUBSCRIBE TO Gawker

Login

Reset Password

Register

Submit Your Comment